320 likes | 643 Vues
Gnosticism. The Quest for Knowledge. Why is Gnosticism hard to grasp?. A belief system Lack of central organization Lack of linear progression. Discovery of Gnostic Documents. Gnostic documents discovered 1945 Muhammad ‘Ali al-Samnan Smuggling scandal. Main Gnostic Tenets.
E N D
Gnosticism The Quest for Knowledge
Why is Gnosticism hard to grasp? • A belief system • Lack of central organization • Lack of linear progression
Discovery of Gnostic Documents • Gnostic documents discovered 1945 • Muhammad ‘Ali al-Samnan • Smuggling scandal
Main Gnostic Tenets • The Godhead and the dyad • The Universe as a prison • Knowledge
Gnosis • Gnosis • Ignorance • Spark of Divine
Reject Jesus’ divinity Reject Resurrection Divine spirit Jesus – Man or God?
Gnosticism v. Christianity • Gnosticism not as popular • Jesus • Personal error • Elitism
The Challenge of Gnosticism • Alternate path • Gnosis contradicted the Church institution
The Gnostic Gospels • Written 150-300 years after Jesus’ death • Not important for historical records • Theological notions
First Gnostic Reference “The cover read: The Gnostic Gospels. Teabing heaved it open, and Langdon and Sophie joined him. Sophie could see it contained photographs of what appeared to be magnified passages of ancient documents – tattered papyrus with handwritten text. ‘These are photocopies of the Nag Hammadi and Dead Sea scrolls, which I mentioned earlier,’ Teabing said. ‘The earliest Christian records. Troublingly, they do not match up with the gospels in the Bible.’” Chapter 58, p. 245-246
Mistakes in the Section • Calls Nag Hammadi documents “scrolls” • Should not be titled “The Gnostic Gospels” • Not “earliest Christian records”
Lutzer, Edward • Ecumenical point of view • Discussion of Gnostic Gospel of Philip
Lutzer’s Interpretation of Philip “The companion is Mary of Magdala. Jesus loved her more than his students. He kissed her often on the ______, more than all his students, and they said, ‘Why do you love her more than us?’” mouth cheek hand face
Brown’s Interpretation of Philip “And the companion of the Savior is Mary Magdalene. Christ loved her more than all the disciples and used to kiss her often on the mouth. The rest of the disciples were offended by it and expressed disapproval. They said to him, ‘Why do you love her more than all of us?’” Chapter 58, p. 246
Lutzer’s Interpretation: Implications • Blank where scholars fill in face • Implies that Jesus kissed the other disciples in the same way
The Aramaic Problem “The words surprised Sophie, and yet they hardly seemed conclusive. ‘It says nothing of marriage.’ ‘Au contraire.’ Teabing smiled, pointing to the first line. ‘As any Aramaic scholar will tell you, the word companion, in those days, literally meant spouse.’” Chapter 58, p. 246
The Aramaic Problem • Brown’s claims about Aramaic scholars, “companion” • Gnostic Gospels are written in Coptic • Differences between Aramaic and Coptic
The Word “Companion” • “any Aramaic scholar” could not tell a Coptic word • “companion” frequently used for friendship
Brown’s Claims About Hieros Gamos • Alleged sex rite Sophie witnesses • Male was incomplete without knowledge of sacred feminine • Hieros Gamos to achieve gnosis
The Truth About Hieros Gamos • “Sacred marriage” - Greek • Success and fertility of the land • Only proper name for agricultural areas who reenact • Inconsistent with Gnostic beliefs
Misinterpretations • Apparent expertise • Some believe Brown is Gnostic • Little serious research