E N D
1. Spill Oil, Kill Birds, Go to Jail: The New Paradigm for Mariners Presentation to: San Francisco Marine Insurance Seminar
May 6-7, 2010
Jeffrey L. BornsteinK&L Gates LLP4 Embarcadero Center, Suite 1200San Francisco, CA 94111
Email: jeff.bornstein@klgates.com
2. The “7 Seas” (or ‘Cs’ in this case) Chain of Errors
Accidents involve a Chain of Errors (but someone will be blamed)
Criminal
If your client spills oil and there is environmental damage, assume there could be Criminal liability
Coverage
Insurance Coverage for criminal counsel and pollution events is essential – protect your clients – their liberty and assets are at risk
Consultation
Before making statements to investigators, your client needs to Consult with legal counsel
Cooperation
The decision to Cooperate with the government (or not) may be different for a company vs. an individual
Compliance
Rigorous Compliance (and training) is an important key to preventing accidents
Communication
Effective Communication between maritime professionals is fundamental
3. The Scene November 7, 2007
A very foggy morning…
4. The Cosco Busan’s bridge was equipped with radars, electronic chart, and manned by the ship’s Master and two officers and an experienced San Francisco Bar Pilot.
5. Cosco Busan
6. Damage to the Cosco Busan
7. Damage to the Bay Bridge Pier
8. Oil Slick on SF Bay 53,500 gallons of oil spilled 2,500 birds killed
Also delayed opening crab season until after Thanksgiving