1 / 102

Standard Terminal Automation Replacement System (STARS) Program Management Review (PMR) No. 31

DRAFT. Standard Terminal Automation Replacement System (STARS) Program Management Review (PMR) No. 31 9 June 1999 Submitted to FAA/DoD. Note: Status is current through 5/28/99. Agenda Wednesday 9 June 1999. General Information Session 10:00AM - 12:00PM System Engineering Terminal

wardah
Télécharger la présentation

Standard Terminal Automation Replacement System (STARS) Program Management Review (PMR) No. 31

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. DRAFT Standard Terminal Automation Replacement System (STARS) Program Management Review (PMR) No. 31 9 June 1999 Submitted to FAA/DoD Note: Status is current through 5/28/99

  2. AgendaWednesday 9 June 1999 • General Information Session 10:00AM - 12:00PM • System Engineering • Terminal • Hardware • Test • ILS • PIT • Program Control • Issues Session 1:00PM - 4:00PM • Issues Discussion • Business Review

  3. EDC Program Highlights • EDC 3.1a SAT underway as of 14 May 1999, completion planned 9 June 1999 • Excellent results to date • Executed 3,362 test steps for 581 shalls • Passed 565 of the 581 shalls (97% pass rate) • EDC 3.1a formal Y2K completed on 21 May 1999 with 100% pass rate • Completed all 3 rollover date tests successfully • 12/31/99 to 1/1/00 • 2/28/00 to 2/29/00 • 2/29/00 to 3/1/00 • Executed 1368 test steps for 83 of 83 total “Green Book” requirements • Passed all 83 “Green Book” requirements

  4. EDC Program Highlights(Continued) • Programmatic discussions for EDC Option 8R are in process • Phase 1 will be EDC 3.1a • Equipment from Reagan National available for deployment in early July 1999 • Will go to Syracuse and El Paso • IOC dates of late this calendar year and early next year • Phase 2 will incorporate • PCI hardware • Combined 3.2/4.0 • IOC of approximately 3Q of CY 2000

  5. EDC Development and Test Schedule (ESL 3.1a) 1999 YEAR ITEM DESCRIPTION MONTH FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JULY Performance changes Build Freeze & merge AT fixes WJHTC readiness test DEMO Merge AF fixes in Fullerton Integration at WJHTC SAT dry runs “CHI 17” partial Clean up Regression Test “CHI 17” Schedule outlook has not changed

  6. Eglin Program Highlights • FSL V7.0 SAT completed 13 May 1999 as planned, excellent cooperation • Completes the incremental test series that included FSL 5.0 and FSL 6.0 SATs • 8726 test steps run, 133 failed. Pass rate of 98.5% • Regression Testing • FSL V7.1 plan is 18 June to 30 June 1999 • ESL V3.1c formal testing is planned from 14 June - 25 June 1999 • SCSC testing is planned from 2 June - 9 June 1999 • Development is on plan for follow-on Eglin builds (7.2 and 7.3) SCSC = STARS Central Support Complex

  7. Eglin Schedule(FSL 7.0/7.1) Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Dev. FSL 7.0 • Baseline Schedule • (per Contract Mod 7) • Includes • - AF Non-CHI • - ASR-11 • - NAS ICD • - DR&A Phase I • (in FSL V7.1) Dev. ESL 3.1b Test Prep SAT Update 7.1, 3.1c ESL FSL R/T DOD DT SAT = System Acceptance Test C/U = Cleanup R/T = Regression Test D/R = Dry Run FS = Full Service ES = Emergency Service

  8. Added Items for ESL 3.3 Added Items for FSL 7.3 • DR&A Phase 2 • CD-2 Weather • Search Radar Filtering • ASR-11 Search Radar Filtering • CD-2 Weather Eglin Schedule(FSL 7.2, 7.3) Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Added Items for FSL 7.2 SSS Req • Emergency codes • Target symbology per • FAA ltr 99-064 SRS Des/Dev Procedure Update Int D/R C/U R/T Needed for DT/OT SSS SRS DEV Int. SRS Dev/Int Proc. Update D/R Needed for MOT&E SAT C/U RT DOD DT/OT DOD DT

  9. ISC Highlights • FSL AT CHI changes that are similar to ESL (note 1) and FSL AF CHI • We are authorized to start • Front end activities (through July) planned • Program planning with FAA is in process • Spiral development in jeopardy • AF unwilling, to date, to partition total task • Need definition of process to get build into site ETG lab • Reminder of FSL CHI and Tower CHI Thin Specs due from the CHI Working Group end of August 1999 • The FSL CHI thin spec shalls will be allocated to two builds/spirals Note 1: • Tool bar (for similar functions) • Knobs/switches • New target Symbology • Transparent windows • ARTS-like command input • Changes to preview window

  10. Budget at Completionby IPT • TBSL

  11. Summary • Early Display Configuration (EDC) • SAT started on 14 May 1999 per plan • SAT completion outlook is 8 June 1999 • Eglin • Testing of FSL 7.0 completed successfully on 13 May 1999 • Outlook is to complete regression testing on 30 June 1999 • Program planning per Option 8R is in process • Early planning activities will not affect the ongoing EDC and Eglin SAT testing and the Eglin key site testing • Y2K testing completed successfully on 21 May 1999

  12. Systems Engineering IPT

  13. Systems EngineeringSummary • Baseline Program • CCB/STRWG requirements issue resolution* • ECP-07 submitted; Work towards SSS Revision C continues* • ESC-1 work continues * • CHI Changes (TO #2) • DRAFT ISC AT CHI ThinSpec under review by CHI Working group • TDW CHI activities resumed June 2 • TCP Control of the Simulator • TIM scheduled for June 16, 17 at Marlboro • Review 61 training observations generated at Oklahoma City • Review Government actions from March 11 TIM (STR 3449) • Raytheon contracts letter submitted per Government request • Revised specification dated June 1 • Raytheon requested authorization to begin software development • Tracking Performance Verification (T0 #3) • Mono- and Multi-Radar Tracking Performance SAT (May 11), verified all of SSS 3.2.1.1.23.5.2 • TIM scheduled for June 16 at Marlboro • Sensitive Application Certification Support (T0 #4) • Security plan taking shape * • Supporting Government SAC Security Assessment* • P3I (T0 #7) • Working actions from ESC-2 TIM • Remote Tower Communications Analysis (T0 #11) • Awaiting completion of Government actions from STARS ICWG#4 *Additional detail in later charts

  14. CCB/SCCB STR Status(3 April 1999) April May CCB (SSS Level) Total Test Imp*. TotalTest Imp*. • Assigned to Raytheon individuals - FSL 12 1 16 0 • Assigned to Raytheon individuals - ESL 2 0 1 0 • Awaiting Government Information 14 1 13 2 • Under Joint review for future ECP 34 36 • Fix Available 1 1 • Future Enhancements 1 2 • Total STRs open 64 2 69 2 • STRs closed in current month 13 7 SCCB (SRS Level) • Assigned to Raytheon individuals - FSL 39 2 42 4 • Assigned to Raytheon individuals - ESL 3 0 9 0 • Subcontractor Verification 3 0 2 0 • Corrected 1 3 • Corrected and verified 8 5 • Documentation 10 8 • Verify Documentation Update 23 24 • Red Lines Approved 10 9 • Fix Available 6 5 • Total STRs open 103 2 107 2 • STRs closed in current month 10 14 * Test Impact = Software change may be needed to pass previously-failed SSS requirement.

  15. STARS ECP Summary # SSS impact currently documented in EDC AT and AF Requirements cross references (STARS-98-0-342, 1998 November 17, and STARS-99-0-141, 1999 April 30 -- reflecting AT CHI updates).

  16. A B C E D X STARS SSS Update plan ECP 9: [EDC AT] ABC, New Trails, Audible Alarms, Tool Bar, ABC HW (4628), TCW Weight (4714), Menu Keys (4367), DCB Dimension (4362), EDC Sys Data Workload (4986), Obscuration by DCB (4666), EASL Symbol (5047) ECP 10: [ISC AF] - FSL subset for Eglin (4052) ECP 8: [EDC AF] AF 5, AF 8, 11 Pass, Workload update (3317), Alarms vs. Alerts (4721) ECP 6: 8 STRs + ECP 7: Heading info (1122), Barom. corr (1125), NAS IF ICD (4108), * echo (STR 2973), alphanum dev (3961), ASR-11 ICD (4220), TCW time (3484), 5 sec. Sampling (1454), UNIX startup (4090), Core keyboard (2782), Search Radar Filter (2610), LRR Weather (915), Target Count (3527), Basic Consolidation (4165), EASL Strobe (4331), Link Timeout (3968), Leader Direction (2991), Workload Columns (4130), 76XX, 77XX (4164), Altitude Filter Limits (4652), FSL Init (4152), Steady State Establishment (4844), SSS Errata (5083), CA/MSAW Scenarios (4767), A/C Type (4916) ECP 4A: 16 STRs + ECP 3B & 5B: VRTM ECP 2A: 11 STRs ECP 1A: STR 557 1998 Dec 22 FINAL 1999 Apr 01 new baseline SSS Draft 1999 May 26* first multi-version SSS 1997Feb28 STARS-1 STARS-1, -2, -3, and -4 STARS System Version: (See backup charts) Directed Draft Plan Denotes SSS Revision X NOTES: - ECP numbers beyond 7 and content are likely to change - See Terminal IPT Charts for details on build content, dates, and target sites * or 30 days after acceptance of updated EDC AT CHI Thin Specs and EDC Cross Reference TIMs [EDC AF] per EDC AF CHI Thin Spec [EDC AT] per EDC AT CHI Thin Specs [ISC AF] per ISC AF CHI Thin Spec [ISC AT] per ISC AT CHI Thin Spec, once approved ECP 12: [ISC AT] New AT CHI ECP 14: ESC-1 ECP 11: [ISC AF] New AF CHI ECP 13: FSC Draft 1999 Nov 15 Draft 2000 May 15 STARS System Version: (See backup charts) STARS- -2, -3, -4 and -5 STARS- -3, -4, -5 and -6 EACH SSS REVISION ADDS NEW VERSION(S) WHILE MAINTAINING REQUIREMENTS SUPPORT FOR ANY PREVIOUS VERSION STILL IN THE FIELD

  17. System Versions(From PMR28, with updates to reflect DRAFT 8R) DIRECTED: DRAFT PLAN:

  18. ICD Status * Contractual Baseline Note: BOLD and shading indicates Government action needed

  19. ESC-1 • Government issued Contract Modification Order DTFA01-96-F-STR01, Modification 26 • Incremental funding of $300K for ESC-1 • Not-to-exceed and total funding changed from $200K to $500K • Raytheon delivered draft versions of ESC-1 ICDs to the FAA • STARS/Surface Movement Advisor • STARS/Precision Runway Monitor • STARS/passive Final Approach Spacing Tool • Raytheon conducted internal review of ESC-1 SSS requirements • Interface Control Working Group meetings are planned for 11-13 May 1999 • ESC-1 team currently consists of ten engineers • 3 systems, 2 software systems, 1 software, 2 hardware, 1 security, 1 test

  20. Sensitive Application Certification Support (TO # 4) • Security Plan • List of 14 Security Analysis and Risk Mitigation activities defined • TO #4 updated (AUA-STARS-99-313) to include new activities • Draft changes to SOW for Option 8R under review • Meant to be long-term replacement for TO #4 • Testbed for draft configuration changes expected to be NE OSF TAS • Subject to AOS authorization and Annex-Z SAT (SCSC) testing schedule • One-Day STARS familiarization seminar being developed for CACI/LLNL personnel • Resource availability remains critical to maintaining schedule • Detailed planning meeting for long-term activities scheduled for late June • Supporting Government SAC Security Assessment • Draft STARS Security Policy under review

  21. Terminal IPT

  22. Terminal IPT Summary Status Overview • Completed FSL V7.0 SAT with 95% pass rate • Completed EDC V3.1a SAT with TBD% pass rate • Completed EDC V3.1a Y2K Testing at Marlboro • All 83 Green Book Requirements Passed • Continued ESL development efforts • ESL V3.2 “AT-17” changes for Version 3, Altitude Filter Readout • ESL V3.3 ASR-11 Search Radar Filtering, CD-2 Weather • ESL V4.0 Remaining AT/AF CHI changes, and “AT-17” changes for Version 4 • Continued FSL development efforts • FSL V7.1 DR&A Phase 1 • FSL V7.2 Emergency Codes and Revised Target Symbology • FSL V7.3 DR&A Phase 2, CD-2 Weather, and Search Radar Filtering • Continued Participation in ISC AT and TDW CHI Working Group Activities

  23. Terminal IPT Summary(Continued) • Began full scale development of ISC AT CHI Software • For functions similar to EDC CHI changes (e.g.: knobs, ABC keyboard) • AF CHI TIM conducted on 11 May 1999

  24. Terminal IPT SummaryProgrammatic • Contract direction required • Option 8R • See Requirements page • Security issues need long term resolution • EDC Security Plan • Security meeting on 5/19 led to clear statement that there are no security gates to Syracuse or El Paso IOC • Eglin Security Plan • Raytheon continuing to proceed with same assumptions as early EDC sites • Longer term requirements, implementation and deployment need definitization • FAA working with DOD to define needs

  25. Emergency Service PT • Supported SAT activities at WJHTC and Marlboro • Supporting dry runs of Eglin SAT procedures • Excellent progress and results to date • Team continues to work off remaining PTRs in preparation for SAT Regression tests • Completed development of Version 3.2 • The V4.0 AF Requirements TIM is scheduled for 16/17 June 1999 • Team continued to support site activities at Eglin AFB

  26. EDC SRB STRS TYPES 1 - 2

  27. EDC SRB STRS TYPES 1 - 4

  28. EDC Requirements Status • EASL performance evaluation identified four areas of concern • Addressed in Release 3.2 but require DCX firmware upgrade; looking for break-in point • Requirements not allocated to EDC Builds • TDW EDC CHI (needs definition) • Additional simulation control features • Awaiting FAA direction to proceed • Clarification of AT notification required upon detection of a TCW/TDW failure • Clarification of display of test targets(PARROTS and PEs)

  29. ESL CHI Activities • NATCA represented at Fullerton during the weeks of 17 May and 24 May 1999 • “Virtual EUIE” • TDW CHI to be addressed by CHI Working Group during the first two weeks of June • ESL V4.0 AF CHI TIM scheduled for 16/17 June 1999

  30. ES Version 3.2 • Purpose • EDC Washington National configuration (ABC keyboard and DCP/DCB) • Supports EDC SAT Regression Testing and FAA OT&E tests • Incorporates STR resolution and “AT 17” changes recommended for Version 3 by EDC CHI WG, and resolution to “Demo 4” • Schedule • AT EDC CHI Thin Specs reviewed on 3 March 1999 • Early User Involvement Events (EUIE) scheduled • EUIE1/Version 4.0 TIM 21 April 1999 in Fullerton • V3.2 ORD 3/4 June in Fullerton • EUIE2 TBD based on CHI WG • Added Requirements Incorporated • “AT 17” changes requested for Version 3 (AUA-STARS-99-081) • EDC CHI Human Factors color scheme (AUA-STARS-98-664) • Altitude Filter Readout in ESL (AUA-STARS-99-022)

  31. ES Version 3.3(EDC and Eglin AFB) • Purpose • Supports both EDC Washington National configuration (ABC keyboard and DCP/DCB) and Eglin AFB configuration (QWERTY keyboard with TracView OIP, and no DCB/DCP) • Schedule • ES Version 3.3 planned for installation at Marlboro and WJHTC on 30 August 1999 • Added Requirements Incorporated • CD-2 weather data processing for ARSR-4 (FAA letters AUA-STARS-98-656, 99-050) • Site adaptable azimuth reporting period • ASR-11 Search Radar Filtering (FAA letter AUA-STARS-99-023) • Quality Filtering • Uncorrelated search target filtering by geographic area

  32. ES Version 4.0 (EDC and Eglin AFB) • Schedule • ES V4.0 TIM conducted on 21 April 1999 in Fullerton (AT portion) • Schedule will be revised based on Option 8R • Version 4.0 incorporates the following additional functions • Planned ES Version 4.0 EDC CHI requirements (preference sets, ATCoach for performance verification, SCSC/OSF I/F monitoring) • Independent history brightness control, and altitude filtering of histories (FAA letter AUA-STARS-99-071) • ASR-9 and search radar filtering (part two) (FAA letter AUA-STARS-98-583) • Conditional quality and confidence filtering • Uncorrelated search target filtering by geographic area • DCB selection for uncorrelated search target filtering • EDC AT-17 changes requested for Version 4 (FAA letter AUA-STARS-99-081)

  33. Full Service PT • FSL Version 7.0 (adds AF non-CHI, ASR-11, NAS ICD) • Completed SAT • FSL Version 7.1 (adds DR&A Phase 1) • System integration complete; FAA attended two SITS held 26/27 May • Team is slightly behind on PTR work-off plan • Caused by focus on V7.0 SAT preparations. Additional staff being applied. • Development for FSL Versions 7.2 and 7.3 is underway • V7.2 adds Emergency Codes and Revised Target Symbology • Software Requirements complete. • Clarifications for symbology are expected. See Requirements Status Page • V7.3 adds DR&A Phase 2, CD-2 Weather, and Search Radar Filtering • Software Requirements complete; Development underway.

  34. ISC Requirements Status • Clarifications for symbology were needed by 16 April 1999; Raytheon is using the following assumptions: • Symbol sizes -- as demonstrated on 25 March 1999 • NAT histories -- None will be displayed • Additional simulation control features • Eglin Security Plan needs definitization

  35. Eglin Schedule(FSL 7.0/7.1) Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Dev. FSL 7.0 • Baseline Schedule • (per Contract Mod 7) • Includes • - AF Non-CHI • - ASR-11 • - NAS ICD • - DR&A Phase I • (in FSL V7.1) Dev. ESL 3.1b Test Prep SAT Update 7.1, 3.1c ESL FSL R/T DOD DT SAT = System Acceptance Test C/U = Cleanup R/T = Regression Test D/R = Dry Run FS = Full Service ES = Emergency Service

  36. Added Items for ESL 3.3 Added Items for FSL 7.3 • DR&A Phase 2 • CD-2 Weather • Search Radar Filtering • ASR-11 Search Radar Filtering • CD-2 Weather Eglin Schedule(FSL 7.2, 7.3) Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Added Items for FSL 7.2 SSS Req • Emergency codes • Target symbology per • FAA ltr 99-064 SRS Des/Dev Procedure Update Int D/R C/U R/T Needed for DT/OT SSS SRS DEV Int. SRS Dev/Int Proc. Update D/R Needed for MOT&E SAT C/U RT DOD DT/OT DOD DT

  37. Eglin FSL PTR Closure Status • The FSL closure rate for Type II PTRs has run below plan for several weeks • This was caused, primarily, by focusing the development and integration teams on 7.0 SAT preparation and conduct • The results of the 7.0 SAT were excellent • Additional resources have been applied and the development and integration teams have been refocused on resolving the remaining Type 2 PTRs

  38. Eglin ISC PTR Status

  39. All ISC PTRs

  40. Type 1/2 ISC PTRs

  41. Data Reduction and Analysis(DR&A) • Ft. Wayne responsible for development • Conducted design review in Ft. Wayne • DR&A Top Level design and test planning competed • DR&A (for FSL V7.3) status • Detailed design complete • Coding 50% complete (needs update from Ivan)

  42. EDC Keysite and EglinAdaptation Validation Status • Raytheon responding aggressively to FAA letter AUA-STARS-99-268 • CCP 81 EDC Keysite and Eglin Adaptation Validation ROM complete; Raytheon management review • Detailed Task Schedule submitted for FAA review (Letter AUA-STARS- 99-162) • Work has commenced for both ISC and EDC Familiarization Materials • Familiarization Material development scheduled earlier than requested to support Desktop reviews (Enhancement to Process) • In order to maintain schedule additional NTE funding required • EDC Keysite selection required by 28 June 1999 to maintain requested schedule

  43. STARS Y2K SUMMARY STATUS • EDC • EDC Y2K Testing Complete, post-test TIM conducted 26 May 1999 • Draft Final Report to FAA by 11June 1999 • ISC • Final FAA comments to ISC Test Plan reviewed and agreed. Final plan (Revision D) will be forwarded to FAA for approval NLT 4 June • FAA Comments on draft ISC Focused Test Procedure reviewed, being incorporated • ISC General Test Procedure reviewed on 24 May with FAA. Comments being incorporated. FAA expects longer test than we originally proposed. We are adjusting our procedure to better reflect FAA expectations. Still expected to be completed within the budgeted effort • Raytheon provided ESL Draft procedure to FAA on 28 April. We notified the FAA Technical Lead last week that we need formal comments (We have received their comments informally). We intend to send final test procedure NLT 15 June 1999 • SCSC/OSF Test Procedure is planned to be conducted at WJHTC (per FAA direction)

  44. STARS Year 2000 (Y2K)Test Activity • Y2K ISC Configuration Tests

  45. STARS Year 2000 (Y2K)Test Activity(Continued) • Y2K SCSC Configuration Tests

  46. Hardware IPT

  47. Summary Status TCW AT CHI • Design/Development completed • Original planned quantity completed and delivered • Replacement quantity for Raytheon Labs in process • Vendor parts received, except for DCP (due early July 1999) • Assembly/wiring started May 1999 • Expect to complete assembly/wiring less DCP by 30 Jun 1999 TDW CHI • No activity this report period • CHI Working Group to restart 01 June 1999

  48. Hardware - PST (Pre-CHI) Summary of Results • Test procedure shalls: • Folder Shalls (30 folders covering 90 items): • Notes: • (1) One (1) open (GPW keyboard illumination; Raytheon Letter, STARS-98-0-098A) • - Demo of external lamp given to FAA on 12 May 99 • - Government action required • (2) Three (3) not presented (all moved to System Test) • - HIA • - Remote TDW interfaces (FSL) • - Remote TDW interfaces (ESL);

  49. Hardware - EDC CHIPST (28-30 Oct 98)Summary of Results • Test procedure shalls: • Folder Shalls (12 folders): • Notes: • (1) Two (2) open Test Procedure steps: • TCW weight (TO) PTR 4714; ECP in process • Fifty percentile female - “depress” Enter Key and Numeric Pad without • relocating her hand; PTR 4628; ECP in process • (2) Five (5) open folder Shalls: • Five (5) ABC Keyboard instead of QWERTY; PTR 4628; ECP in • process • (3) Three (3) folder Shalls for Lightning Arrestor UL; consider closed • Tests successfully completed; formal report sent to FAA

  50. PCI ConversionOverview • PCI Conversion Design Review/TIM held 04 May 1999 at FAA Tech Center • CDRL Submitted 18 May 1999 • Six (6) Action Items, four (4) completed Raytheon Marlboro Path Finding Lab • Reorganization, including addition of two (2) TCW’s and one (1) TDW, completed • Lab now operational; minor problems being resolved • Engineering testing restarted 01 Jun 1999 Tech-Source • X-Server Version Beta 7 has a problem in “Health Checking”. • Fix anticipated by 04 Jun 1999

More Related