E N D
1. 1 ANSI/ADA Specification No. 1058: The Forensic Dental Data Set
What Should we measure?
ANSI/ADA Specification No. 1058: The Forensic Dental Data Set
What Should we measure?
2. 11 de Septiembre 2001 Reportadas como desaparecidas:
Inicialmente 30.000 (de 88 pases extranjeros)
Revisado 2.753 de 67 pases extranjeros
1,7 millones de toneladas los residuos
20,000 + sigue siendo 2 September 11, 2001
Reported missing:
Initially 30,000 (from 88 foreign countries)
Revised 2,753 from 67 foreign countries
1.7 million tons debris
20,000 + remains September 11, 2001
Reported missing:
Initially 30,000 (from 88 foreign countries)
Revised 2,753 from 67 foreign countries
1.7 million tons debris
20,000 + remains
3. WTC Estadstica de Noviembre de 2011 3 WTC Statistics as of November 2011
Victims Not Identified
Dental X-Rays
Reported Missing
Victims identified
Victims Who Died Outside NYC
Victims Not Identified
Victims identified By a Single Modality
DNA
Dental X-Rays
Fingerprints
Photograph
Remains Viewed
Personal Effects
Other
WTC Statistics as of November 2011
Victims Not Identified
Dental X-Rays
Reported Missing
Victims identified
Victims Who Died Outside NYC
Victims Not Identified
Victims identified By a Single Modality
DNA
Dental X-Rays
Fingerprints
Photograph
Remains Viewed
Personal Effects
Other
4. WTC Estadstica de Noviembre de 2011 4 WTC Statistics as of November 2011
MULTIPLE MODALITIES
Dental X-Rays
Remains Recovered
Remains Identified
Remains Not identified
Victims identified By a Multiple Modality
DNA
Dental X-Rays
Fingerprints
Photo
Remains Viewed
Body X-Ray
Personal Effects
Tattoos
Other WTC Statistics as of November 2011
MULTIPLE MODALITIES
Dental X-Rays
Remains Recovered
Remains Identified
Remains Not identified
Victims identified By a Multiple Modality
DNA
Dental X-Rays
Fingerprints
Photo
Remains Viewed
Body X-Ray
Personal Effects
Tattoos
Other
5. 11 de Septiembre 2001 Identificacin De Vctimas De Desastres De Registros Dentales Ante Mortem En Una Torre De Babel 5 September 11, 2001
Disaster Victim Identification (DVI) Antemortem Dental Records Were a Tower of BabelSeptember 11, 2001
Disaster Victim Identification (DVI) Antemortem Dental Records Were a Tower of Babel
6. La Cuestin Podemos mejorar la recoleccin de datos antes de la muerte? 6 The Question
Can we improve antemortem data collection?
The Question
Can we improve antemortem data collection?
7. El comienzo - Febrero 2003 Artculo publicado en ADA News indica el deseo de crear un estndar de Odontologa Forense 7 The Beginning - February 2003
Article Published in the ADA News stating the desire to create a Forensic Odontology Standard
The Beginning - February 2003
Article Published in the ADA News stating the desire to create a Forensic Odontology Standard
8. Trabaje Flujo Original 8 Original Work Flow
Practice Management Software
Intermediate Language
Electronic
Transfer
Original Work Flow
Practice Management Software
Intermediate Language
Electronic
Transfer
9. Necesitamos De Software Que Puedan Trabajar Juntos! 9 We Need Software That Can Work Together!We Need Software That Can Work Together!
10. Fondo La primavera de 2003 - ADA anuncia la formacin de una Comisin Forense Dental
Se solicitan voluntarios 2003-2006
El otoo de 2006 ADA Reunin de Las Vegas - Propuesta formal presentada al ADA Comit de Normas de Informtica Dental (SCDI)
Mocin aprobada con tres co-presidentes
Dr. Norman Schreiber
Dr. Mark Diehl
Dr. Kenneth W. Aschheim 10 Background
Spring 2003 ADA announces the Formation of a Dental Forensic Committee
Call for Volunteers 2003-2006
Fall 2006 ADA Meeting Las Vegas Formal Proposal placed before ADA Standards Committee for Dental Informatics (SCDI)
Motion Approved with Three Co-Chairpersons
Dr. Norman Schreiber
Dr. Mark Diehl
Dr. Kenneth W. Aschheim
Background
Spring 2003 ADA announces the Formation of a Dental Forensic Committee
Call for Volunteers 2003-2006
Fall 2006 ADA Meeting Las Vegas Formal Proposal placed before ADA Standards Committee for Dental Informatics (SCDI)
Motion Approved with Three Co-Chairpersons
Dr. Norman Schreiber
Dr. Mark Diehl
Dr. Kenneth W. Aschheim
11. ADA y Codificacin Forense 11 La creacin de normas tcnicas relativas a la recopilacin de informacin forense Dental Solicitud de Nuevos elementos de trabajo - 2006 ADA and Forensic Coding
New Working Item Request 2006
The Creation of Technical Standards Concerning the Collection of Dental Forensic Information
ADA and Forensic Coding
New Working Item Request 2006
The Creation of Technical Standards Concerning the Collection of Dental Forensic Information
12. El Objetivo Propuesta de ADA Especificacin N 1058 - Para formular una nueva lista de datos forense dentales conjunto de datos mnimos y opcionales que ayudarn en la determinacin de la identidad de una vctima desconocida. 12 The Goal
Proposed ADA Specification No. 1058 - To formulate a new forensic dental data set of minimal and optional data that will aid in the determination of the identity of an unknown victim.
The Goal
Proposed ADA Specification No. 1058 - To formulate a new forensic dental data set of minimal and optional data that will aid in the determination of the identity of an unknown victim.
13. Historia 2006-2007 documento preliminar
Septiembre 2007 - Primera reunin del grupo de trabajo en la Sesin Anual de la ADA - San Francisco
Septiembre 2007 - ADA mesa redonda sobre la odontologa forense 13 History
2006-2007 Preliminary seed document was created
September 2007 First meeting of working group at the ADA Annual Session - San Francisco
September 2007 ADA round table on forensic odontology
History
2006-2007 Preliminary seed document was created
September 2007 First meeting of working group at the ADA Annual Session - San Francisco
September 2007 ADA round table on forensic odontology
14. 2008 - Reuniones de grupo de trabajo Historia 14 History
2008 -2010 Subsequent meetings of working group
We Want Everything
History
2008 -2010 Subsequent meetings of working group
We Want Everything
15. Por qu hacemos nosotros esto? Preguntas Ms Frequentes La Salud electrnica Registra (EHR) ha sido puesto bajo el mandato por El Ministerio de Sanidad y Seguridad Social (SAS) por 2015. Queramos estar seguros de que la odontologa forense se incluirn. 15 Question Answer Frequently Asked Questions
Question
Why are we doing this?
Answer
ELECTRONIC Health Records (EHR) have been mandated by The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) by 2015..
Frequently Asked Questions
Question
Why are we doing this?
Answer
ELECTRONIC Health Records (EHR) have been mandated by The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) by 2015..
16. 16 Frequently Asked Questions
Electronic Health Record
Forensic Dental Data
Frequently Asked Questions
Electronic Health Record
Forensic Dental Data
17. 17 Miembros electorales Chairperson - Kenneth W. Aschheim, DDS
ABFO Bob Barsley, DDS ABFO
AAFS Thomas David, DDS ABFO
ASFO Ken Hermsen, DDS
ACP and VA - Stephen Bergen, DDS
A Ped D - Rhea M. Haugseth, DMD
AGD - Jim Schneider DDS
Ed - Mary Cimrmancic DDS
AFIP - Duane R. Schafer, CAPT, DC, USN
Pub Health - Robin Scheper, DMD
Pub Health - Scott A. Trapp, DDS (ADA)
Gov - NCIC (Gary L. Bell DDS
FBI-CJIS Cindy Johnston (observer) ME Odont - Lawrence Dobrin, DMD
ME Radiology Richard Weledniger, DDS
ME Odont Harry Zohn, DDS
ME Anthropology Donna Fontana, MS
ADHA Winnie Furnari, MS Secretary
Informatics - Mark Diehl, DDS
Industry Rad - Candy Ross, (Dexis)
Industry PMS Zach Church, (Dentrix)
Industry - Dianne Rose, (Insurance)
ADA - Pamela Porembski, DDS
ADA - Norman Schreiber, DDS
ADA - Greg Zeller, DDS
ADA - Sharon Sanford
Voting Members
broad cross-section of OdontologyVoting Members
broad cross-section of Odontology
18. Marco para los datos Ante-mortem Dental Set 18 Framework For Postmortem Dental Data Set
Familial Data Set
Dental History Data Set
Tooth Data Set
Mouth Data Set
Visual Image Data Set
Framework For Postmortem Dental Data Set
Familial Data Set
Dental History Data Set
Tooth Data Set
Mouth Data Set
Visual Image Data Set
19. Marco Para Los Datos Post-mortem Dental Set 19 Framework For Postmortem Dental Data Set
Familial Data Set
Dental History Data Set
Tooth Data Set
Mouth Data Set
Visual Image Data Set
Framework For Postmortem Dental Data Set
Familial Data Set
Dental History Data Set
Tooth Data Set
Mouth Data Set
Visual Image Data Set
20. Descriptores Cada producto en el conjunto de datos fue acompaada con una explicacin clara de los Descriptores para asegurarse de que se apliquen de manera consistente Descriptors
Each Item in the Data Set was accompanied with an unambiguous explanation of the Descriptors to make sure it is applied in a consistent manner
Descriptors
Each Item in the Data Set was accompanied with an unambiguous explanation of the Descriptors to make sure it is applied in a consistent manner
21. Cul es el propsito de los Descriptores?
Preguntas Ms Frequentes El propsito de los descriptores es de ser cierto que hablamos todo el "mismo idioma" 21 Question Answer Frequently Asked Questions
Question
Why is the purpose of the Descriptors?
Answer
The purpose of the descriptors is to be certain that we are all talking the same language
Frequently Asked Questions
Question
Why is the purpose of the Descriptors?
Answer
The purpose of the descriptors is to be certain that we are all talking the same language
22. Puede dar un ejemplo? Preguntas Ms Frequentes Algo tan sencillo como un nombre puede ser ambiguo. Qu tal un apodo, etc. o apellidos de soltera.
22 "Nombre - Este Descriptor es utilizado para describir el nombre legal del paciente como parecera en documentos oficiales" "Alias comn de Nombre ("Apodo ") - Este Descriptor debe ser utilizado para describir un nombre preferente los usos de paciente".
Frequently Asked Questions
Question
Can you give an example?
Answer
Something as simple as a name can be ambiguous. What about nicknames, maiden names etc. so
Name - This Descriptor is used to describe the legal name of the patient as it would appear on official (government) documents.
Common Name Alias (Nickname ) - This Descriptor should be used to describe a preferential name the patient uses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Question
Can you give an example?
Answer
Something as simple as a name can be ambiguous. What about nicknames, maiden names etc. so
Name - This Descriptor is used to describe the legal name of the patient as it would appear on official (government) documents.
Common Name Alias (Nickname ) - This Descriptor should be used to describe a preferential name the patient uses.
23. Qu tal un ejemplo dental simple?
Preguntas Ms Frequentes De metal (color oro) - Este descriptor se utiliza para describir cualquier restauracin de metal todos los que predominantemente de color parece ser de oro. Este descriptor se utiliza independientemente de la composicin del material. 23 Frequently Asked Questions
Question
How about a simple dental example?
Answer
Metal (Gold Colored) - This descriptor is used to describe any all metal restoration whose predominantly color appears to be gold. This descriptor is used regardless of the composition of the material. Frequently Asked Questions
Question
How about a simple dental example?
Answer
Metal (Gold Colored) - This descriptor is used to describe any all metal restoration whose predominantly color appears to be gold. This descriptor is used regardless of the composition of the material.
24. por qu hay tantos cdigos? Preguntas Ms Frequentes Si un descriptor de falta, no habr forma de transferir electrnicamente una cierta caracterstica de una pieza de software a otro 24 Frequently Asked Questions
Question
So why are there so many codes?
Answer
If a Descriptor is missing there will be no way to electronically transfer a certain characteristic from one piece of software to another
Frequently Asked Questions
Question
So why are there so many codes?
Answer
If a Descriptor is missing there will be no way to electronically transfer a certain characteristic from one piece of software to another
25. El resultado La primavera de 2010 - Seattle WA - 10.12 GMT de datos Dental Forense Grupo de Trabajo examin los comentarios y actualizados los estndares de acuerdo
Primavera - Verano 2010 SCDI Comit de Supervisin da la aprobacin final y la norma se enva al Consejo de la ADA en la prctica dental 25 The Result
Spring 2010 Seattle WA - JWG 10.12 Forensic Dental Data Working Group reviewed comments and updated the standard accordingly
Spring Summer 2010 SCDI Oversight Committee gives final approval and standard is sent to the ADA Council on Dental Practice.
Forensic Dental Data Set Approved Fall 2010
The Result
Spring 2010 Seattle WA - JWG 10.12 Forensic Dental Data Working Group reviewed comments and updated the standard accordingly
Spring Summer 2010 SCDI Oversight Committee gives final approval and standard is sent to the ADA Council on Dental Practice.
Forensic Dental Data Set Approved Fall 2010
26. Fall 2010 26 Fall 2010
ANSI Standard Is published Fall 2010
ANSI Standard Is published
27. El Resultado Los Datos Dentales forenses Giro Final Fijo APROBADO Por ANSI
Noviembre-Diciembre 2010
Oficialmente conocido
como Estndar de ANSI 1058 27 The Result
Forensic Dental Data Set Final Draft APPROVED By ANSI
November-December 2010
Officially known as ANSI Standard 1058
The Result
Forensic Dental Data Set Final Draft APPROVED By ANSI
November-December 2010
Officially known as ANSI Standard 1058
28. Vctima del Sistema nico de Identificacin (UVIS) Se arregla DVI ciudad de Nueva York
financiado por el gobierno federal
libres de derechos
Separados UVIS Mdulo de identificacin dental (UDIM)
Queramos mantener la compatibilidad 28 Unified Victim Identification System (UVIS)
Manages New York Citys DVI needs
Federally financed
Royalty free
Separate UVIS Dental Identification Module (UDIM)
We wanted to maintain compatibility
Unified Victim Identification System (UVIS)
Manages New York Citys DVI needs
Federally financed
Royalty free
Separate UVIS Dental Identification Module (UDIM)
We wanted to maintain compatibility
29. La Reunin de Interpol/Plass DIV febrero 7-8th 2011 Dr. David Senn Co-Chair FBI Scientific Working Group (SWG) Forensics Odontology
Dr. David Sweet - Interpol Forensics Odontology
Dr. Lawrence Dobrin - Chief Forensic Odontologist NYC
Rene Pape Plass Dental
Lynn Aspinall - BKA
Elias Kontanis - Coordinator-Medicolegal Operations at National Transportation Safety Board
Frank DePaulo - Assistant Commissioner NYC Emergency Management 29 Interpol/Plass DVI Meeting Feb. 7-8th 2011
Dr. David Senn Co-Chair FBI Scientific Working Group (SWG) Forensics Odontology
Dr. David Sweet - Interpol Forensics Odontology
Dr. Lawrence Dobrin - Chief Forensic Odontologist NYC
Rene Pape Plass Dental
Elias Kontanis - Coordinator-Medicolegal Operations at National Transportation Safety Board
Frank DePaulo - Assistant Commissioner NYC Emergency Management
Interpol/Plass DVI Meeting Feb. 7-8th 2011
Dr. David Senn Co-Chair FBI Scientific Working Group (SWG) Forensics Odontology
Dr. David Sweet - Interpol Forensics Odontology
Dr. Lawrence Dobrin - Chief Forensic Odontologist NYC
Rene Pape Plass Dental
Elias Kontanis - Coordinator-Medicolegal Operations at National Transportation Safety Board
Frank DePaulo - Assistant Commissioner NYC Emergency Management
30. La Reunin De Interpol/Plass DIV 26 A 27 Junio, 2010 Dr. David Senn Co-Chair FBI Scientific Working Group (SWG) Forensics Odontology
Rene Pape Plass Dental
Alain Middleton - Interpol (Australia) Forensics Odontology
Eddy De Valck - Interpol (Belgium) Forensics Odontology
Irena Dawidson - Interpol (Sweden) Forensics Odontology 30 Interpol/Plass DVI Meeting June 26th -27th 2011
Dr. David Senn Co-Chair FBI Scientific Working Group (SWG) Forensics Odontology
Rene Pape Plass Dental
Alain Middleton - Interpol (Australia) Forensics Odontology
Eddy De Valck - Interpol (Belgium) Forensics Odontology
Irena Dawidson - Interpol (Sweden) Forensics Odontology
Interpol/Plass DVI Meeting June 26th -27th 2011
Dr. David Senn Co-Chair FBI Scientific Working Group (SWG) Forensics Odontology
Rene Pape Plass Dental
Alain Middleton - Interpol (Australia) Forensics Odontology
Eddy De Valck - Interpol (Belgium) Forensics Odontology
Irena Dawidson - Interpol (Sweden) Forensics Odontology
31. Los Asuntos Para compartir BIDIRECCIONAL de datos dentales dos cosas deben ser presentes
La interpretacin sin ambigedades del significado de cdigos
UNA relacin de uno a uno entre conjuntos de datos 31 The Issues
For BIDIRECTIONAL sharing of dental data two things must be present
Unambiguous interpretation of the meaning of codes
A one-to-one relationship between data sets
The Issues
For BIDIRECTIONAL sharing of dental data two things must be present
Unambiguous interpretation of the meaning of codes
A one-to-one relationship between data sets
32. Plass DIV Dental Forma 32 Plass DVI Dental FormsPlass DVI Dental Forms
33. Plass DIV Dental Codifica 33 Plass DVI Dental CodesPlass DVI Dental Codes
34. 34 Utilizar Los Datos de ANSI Ponen Utilizing The ANSI Data Set
One-To-One Relationship Means Unambiguous Data Transfer
One to One ?????
Utilizing The ANSI Data Set
One-To-One Relationship Means Unambiguous Data Transfer
One to One ?????
35. Estado Actual Fase 1 de la norma ADA se ha formalizado
Fase 2 (definicin de estndares electrnicos)
Necesidad de esperar a que EHR Se define
Utilizados con el estndar XML
Inicialmente desarrollado como un PMS para FMS puente puede terminar sirviendo como FMS - FMS Puente Current Status
Phase 1 of the ADA Standard has been formalized
Phase 2 (Electronic standards definition) will either
Need to wait till EHR Is defined
Utilized using XML standard
Initially developed as a PMS to FMS bridge may end up serving as a FMS FMS Bridge
Current Status
Phase 1 of the ADA Standard has been formalized
Phase 2 (Electronic standards definition) will either
Need to wait till EHR Is defined
Utilized using XML standard
Initially developed as a PMS to FMS bridge may end up serving as a FMS FMS Bridge
36. NIST Special Publication 500-271 36 NIST Special Publication 500-271NIST Special Publication 500-271
37. Otras Investigaciones Referencia de base de datos de los datos forenses dentales (50.000 vctimas)
Direccin lgica del cambio
Composicin de control de datos (de Desastres, la fragmentacin, persona desaparecida)
Optimizacin de los algoritmos de clasificacin 37 Other Research
Reference database of dental forensics data (50,000 victims)
Logicial direction of change
Control Composition of Data (Disaster, Fragmentation, Missing Person)
Optimization of Ranking Algorithms
Other Research
Reference database of dental forensics data (50,000 victims)
Logicial direction of change
Control Composition of Data (Disaster, Fragmentation, Missing Person)
Optimization of Ranking Algorithms
38. UVIS - CMS Bitemark Mdulo 38 UVIS CMS Bitemark Module
American Board Of Forensic Odontologist Descriptors - UVIS CMS Bitemark Module
American Board Of Forensic Odontologist Descriptors -
39. UVIS - CMS Mdulo De Anlisis De La Edad 39 UVIS CMS Age Analysis ModuleUVIS CMS Age Analysis Module
40. UVIS - CMS Mdulo De Anlisis De La Edad 40 UVIS CMS Age Analysis ModuleUVIS CMS Age Analysis Module
41. Questions??? 41