240 likes | 548 Vues
Euthanasia. Comparative Ethics and Law. What is Euthanasia?. “granting painless death to a hopelessly ill patient with a non-curable disease.” Distinction between euthanasia and murder. Types of Euthanasia. Passive Voluntary Involuntary Active. Historical Review.
E N D
Euthanasia Comparative Ethics and Law
What is Euthanasia? • “granting painless death to a hopelessly ill patient with a non-curable disease.” • Distinction between euthanasia and murder
Types of Euthanasia • Passive • Voluntary • Involuntary • Active
Historical Review • Before the Twentieth Century… • Socrates • Plato • Aristotle • Sixth Commandment • Hippocratic Oath • Dr. Charles Goddard
1930’s • Euthanasia Society • Voluntary Euthanasia Bill
1940’s • Judge Earengey of England • Geneva version of Oath
1950’s • Dr. Joseph Fletcher “society is willing to oppose death but not permit it”
1960’s • Living Will • Euthanasia Educational Fund
1970’s • Natural death laws • Case of Karen Ann Quinlan
Movement for Euthanasia • Derek Humphry • Jean’s Way • Hemlock Society • Dr. Jack Kevorkian • Nancy Cruzan
Opinions on Euthanasia • Dr. Charles Dougherty - “legalizing euthanasia would harm society” • William Carr - “people will want the comfort of knowing that if they choose, a physician will be ready, willing, and able to help them…by offering a death with dignity”
Dr. Timothy Quill - “important goals are not about assisted suicide but about good care for dying people • Dr. Arthur Caplan - “assisted suicide is going to become and attractive solution”
Ethical Standpoint • Religious Beliefs (Roman Catholic) • Ronald Otremba- “active euthanasia is never morally justified” • Derek Humphry- “decisions about dying are highly personal and that euthanasia should not be denied to those who choose it”
Euthanasia and Public Policy • Current Legislation • Oregon legalizing euthanasia (Death with Dignity Act) • Legislation of euthanasia in other countries
As of Now… • Derek Humphry today • 1999 sentence of Jack Kevorkian • Pain Relief Promotion Act • Still a debatable subject and will continue to be….