120 likes | 247 Vues
The Great Constitution Debate centers on the contrasting views of Federalists and Anti-Federalists regarding the balance of power between a strong national government and state sovereignty. The Federalists, led by figures like Hamilton and Madison, advocated for a robust federal government to protect rights and ensure unity. In contrast, Anti-Federalists, represented by leaders like Patrick Henry, feared that a powerful federal government might infringe on individual liberties. This debate ultimately shaped the Constitution, emphasizing the need for a stronger federal structure than the Articles of Confederation, while still ensuring a measured distribution of power.
E N D
DBQs and Essay due Friday • I will be after school in Room 1216 on Monday, Wednesday and Thursday to help with your papers! If you have questions, please see me before Friday. • Please attach rubric to DBQs and Essay!!!
The Great Constitution Debate Compare and contrast the differences between the views of Federalists and Anti-Federalists
How did the Articles of Confederation divide up power? • WEAK national government, STRONG states Federal Federal Why? • To avoid a repeat of the oppressions of Great Britain. What happened? • The Articles FAILED – not enough unity, not enough power to the national government
What differences do you think we will see in the new Constitution? And now all Americans will agree that it’s a wonderful document, right? WRONG!
Federalists and Antifederalists The two sides in the Great Constitution Debate
Federalists • Support a strong federal (national) government • Support the Constitution • Key figures: • Alexander Hamilton • James Madison • John Jay • Wrote The Federalist Papers to convince Americans to support the Constitution
Values of Federalists • Strong federal government can: • Protect people’s rights • Force states to participate, pay taxes, contribute to the union • Fulfill the tasks required to run a country • Federalists tended to be wealthy, well-educated, and urban/industrial.
Antifederalists • Feared a strong federal government • Opposed the Constitution • Key figure: • Patrick Henry “Give me liberty, or give me death!”
Values of Antifederalists • Strong federal governments can: • Take away people’s rights • Exercise too much power • Antifederalists tended to believe government works best in smaller communities where all people participate and know each other. • They were mostly rural/agricultural.
The Constitution must have a stronger FEDERAL gov’t than the Articles, but not so strong that Antifederalists will vote against it.We want the new document to be approved! ratified
Elements that strengthen federal power • Article I.18 is called the Elastic Clause. Why? • Elastic Clause: Constitution gives the national government the power to do anything “necessary and proper” to accomplish its tasks.
Elements that strengthen FEDERAL power • The original Constitution did not have a Bill of Rights. It did not list the specific rights of Individuals that government can never take away.