300 likes | 447 Vues
Pacific Asian Countries in International Trade. Young Jo Lee Graduate School of Pan-Pacific International Studies May 13, 2004. Contents. Avid traders Shift toward manufactured exports Open domestic markets Upgrading of products Region-wide sequential catch-up No regional PTA
E N D
Pacific Asian Countries in International Trade Young Jo Lee Graduate School of Pan-Pacific International Studies May 13, 2004
Contents • Avid traders • Shift toward manufactured exports • Open domestic markets • Upgrading of products • Region-wide sequential catch-up • No regional PTA • Mushrooming bilateral FTAs Young Jo Lee
Feature 1Avid Traders Young Jo Lee
Trade Ratios of Asian & LA Countries Young Jo Lee
ELI & Trade • ELI High trade dependence • Not only exports but also imports • Two Factors that favored ELI strategy • Poor natural endowments • Small domestic markets Young Jo Lee
Feature 2Shift toward Manufactured Exports Young Jo Lee
Manufactured Exports as % of Total Exports Young Jo Lee
RCA of Asian Countries, 1995 Young Jo Lee
Feature 3Open Domestic Markets Young Jo Lee
ELI, No Modern Mercantilism • Tariffs and NTBs shrinking rapidly Young Jo Lee
Feature 4Upgrading of Products • Moving into new growing markets • Shift toward more technology intensive industries Young Jo Lee
Growth Intensity Index (GI) • Weighted average of a country’s export growth rates relative to world demands (=exports=imports=markets) in different industries • GI larger than 1 indicates a county’s exports are concentrated in industries with a rapid growth in world demand Young Jo Lee
GI for 1st Tier Asian NICs Young Jo Lee
GI for 2nd Tier Asian NICs Young Jo Lee
GI for Indonesia & China Young Jo Lee
Demand Growth & Knowledge Intensity • Growth in world import demand correlates strongly with product innovation and knowledge intensity • The more knowledge intensive an industry is, the more rapidly it grows (Exception: aerospace industry) • Asian countries’ penetration into rapidly growing market means that they succeeded in industrial upgrading Young Jo Lee
Cases: Korea & Singapore • Korea • ELI chosen around 1963 after a decade of ISI • Heavy-chemical industrialization in the 70s • Electronics in the 1980s • Singapore • Gave up ISI for ELI when unification w Malaysia failed • “2nd Industrial Revolution” (1979) in favor of capital-intensive industries • New Economic Policy (1986), Strategic Economic Plan (1991), and Singapore 2000 (1996) Young Jo Lee
Feature 5Region-Wide Sequential Catch-up Young Jo Lee
Flying Geese Pattern of Dev Young Jo Lee
Source: Intra-Regional FDI • Intra-regional FDI regional production networks • Japan as a model & source of capital & technology for 1st tier NICs • Japan & 1st tier NICs as models & sources of capital & technology for 2nd tier NICs • Plaza Accord of 1985 Young Jo Lee
Private Capital Flows (% of GDP) Young Jo Lee
Feature 6No Regional PTA Young Jo Lee
No Region-Wide PTA • Dense invisible linkages • Regional production networks • Ethnic Chinese networks • Subregional economic zones • But no regional PTA • Even bilateral PTA is rare in the region • At end of 2001, China, Hong Kong, Japan, Korea, Taiwan & Mongolia were the only countries that were not parties to any PTA Young Jo Lee
Why No Region-Wide PTA? • Wide divergence among Asian economies • Lack of leadership • Japan: burden of history • China: Not ready yet, Japan wary • External opposition • USA against any PTA that includes Japan but excludes USA • APEC in place of EAEC Young Jo Lee
Feature 7Mushrooming Bilateral FTAs Young Jo Lee
Bilateral FTAs in Pacific Asia • 30+ bilateral FTAs in the last 4 years • Why? • Increasing awareness of weakness of existing arrangements (APEC, ASEAN, ASEM), esp. after Asian crisis • Demonstration effects from regional blocs elsewhere • Changing configuration of domestic eco interests • Uneven distribution • Led by more developed countries • More inter-regional than intra-regional Young Jo Lee
Pacific Asian Countries in PTA Young Jo Lee
Economic Effects? • Most are politically safe FTAs • That is why partners outside the region are preferred • Economic effects will not be large • FTAs with relatively insignificant partners (Exception: USA-Singapore FTA) • Mostly between complimentary, not competing, economies • Sensitive industries are excluded Young Jo Lee
Share of FTA Partners in Countries’ Total Exports (2000) Young Jo Lee
Will the pattern continue? • Challenges • Technological catch-up in face of narrowing technological gap • China’s rise & scattering geese • Tasks • Technological capabilities (skills, education, R&D) • Channels of technology transfer • Incentive structures • More authentic FTAs • Greater insertion into & utilization of WTO regime Young Jo Lee