940 likes | 1.39k Vues
Insights from experimentally infecting humans with hookworm. Emeritus Professor Rick Speare School of Public Health, Tropical Medicine and Rehabilitation Sciences, James Cook University & Director, Tropical Health Solutions Townsville, Queensland, Australia 17 October 2012.
E N D
Insights from experimentally infecting humans with hookworm Emeritus Professor Rick Speare School of Public Health, Tropical Medicine and Rehabilitation Sciences, James Cook University & Director, Tropical Health Solutions Townsville, Queensland, Australia 17 October 2012 Presentation to Medical Research Council (Gambia) • Available at: http//www.tropicalhealthsolutions.com/hookworm
Orientation - map Townsville Anton Breinl Centre for Public Health and Tropical Medicine
Hygiene Hypothesis: STH style • Although soil transmitted helminths (STH) cause significant morbidity in developing countries, the lack of STH in developed countries is hypothesised to increase the incidence of allergic and autoimmune disease. • STH will induce a Th2 response against the parasite and this will be down-regulated by regulatory T cells which will also non-specifically down-regulate the destructive immune response (Th1) of the host that is responsible for allergic and autoimmune diseases.
Relationship between prevalence of multiple sclerosis and STH Fleming & Cook. Neurology 2006;67:2085 • Trichuris trichiura as a marker of STH & low levels of community sanitation • Prevalence of MS & Tt in 35 countries • Correlational study
Multiple Sclerosis vs Whipworm Fleming & Cook. Neurology 2006;67:2085 • Prevalence of MS falls steeply once threshold of 10% Tt is reached • This applied for marginalised populations sharing same country (Jews – Arabs in Israel) 10% Is the protective effect due to Tt or gut exposure to pathogens?
Some worms are protective; some aren’t: Care is needed! • Meta-analysis of asthma and association with STH • STH in general no significant effect • Ascaris is associated with asthma • Hookworm is protective Leonardi-Bee et al Am J Resp Crit Care Med 2006;174:514
Effect of anthelmintics on allergic reactions Skin reactivity to dust mite antigen increased after STH controlled • Van den Biggelaar et al J Inf Dis 2004;189:892
How do parasites exert an effect? • Brown & Jackson Para Immunol 2004;26:429 Immune response
Trichuris suis for IBD • Whipworm eggs collected from worms in experimentally infected pigs • Incubated, made aseptic • 2500 eggs orally every 3 weeks
All open trials • Significant percent of remissions for both Crohn’s Disease and Ulcerative Colitis • No significant side effects 80% of patients benefited Summers et al. Gut 2005;54:87 Summers et al. Am J Gastrolenterol 2003;98:2034
Life cycle • Skin penetration • Blood-lung migration • Occurs within 48 hrs PI • Juvenile worms arrive in smint in 4 weeks PI • Adults mature at 7-8 weeks PI
N. americanus in gut • Attaches to mucosa of small intestine • Sucks blood • Little known about behaviour of NA in human gut since can not be directly observed
Harada-Mori Technique • 25°C • In dark • 7 days
Infection worked! • We inoculated 9 immunosuppressed Crohn’s disease patients and 3 normal donors with 15 to 101 L3i • All 9 Crohn’s patients and 2/3 donors developed a patent infection Insight: Imunosuppressed and normal hosts can be infected with Necator with no or minimal negative effects.
What did the hosts think? • Human hosts loved their worms! Insight: Finding subjects to be inoculated with hookworms is not difficult.
Some problems! • Penetration site • Small intestine
Severe local response on reinfection Insight: Penetration of L3i is uneventful in most, worrying in some
L3i are “dirty” • L3i are heavily contaminated with faecal bacteria. • Standard techniques of multiple washing do not reduce the contamination. • Is the hookworm sheath left on skin or does it remain in epidermis? • Washing in providone iodine for 15 min was added after harvesting. • Could L3i be made sterile?
Better Quality L3i • Melissa Logan – BMedLabSc honours thesis Bacteria are associated with L3i
In vivo tests: penetration • 15 L3i; 3 groups – 5 subjects per group
Patency of infection • 100% patency for both techniques Antibiotic treated L3i were equivalent to standard L3i
Conclusion • Treatment of L3i with bleach and antibiotics gives viable larvae of comparable potency. • These L3i are sterile. • Bleach and antibiotic technique should be the gold standard for L3i for experimental infection.
Recommended Protocol • Harvest L3i and centrifuge • Place in 0.25% sodium hypochlorite for 10 mins • Wash twice using centrifugation in sterile distilled water to remove any residual sodium hypochlorite • Place in a solution of benzylepenicillin (180 mg/L) and ceftazadime (1.0 mg/L) for 60 mins • Centrifuge to remove excess solution • Wash L3i twice using centrifugation in sterile distilled water to remove any residual antibiotic solution. Are skin reactions less?
Safety when working with L3i • For any item in the laboratory a Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) is needed. • MSDS important when L3i of N. americanus are being used in laboratory. • The MSDS for hookworm said kill spills of L3i with bleach (Health Canada 2001). • Did this actually work?
What kills L3i rapidly? • Bleach did not kill L3i • Ethanol 70-100% did • Dettol killed L3i Insight: Current MSDS was inaccurate! A new one based on evidence was needed.
New Hookworm MSDS • Speare et al. Australian Journal of Medical Science 2008;29:91-96. • Online at http://www.tropicalhealthsolutions.com/MSDSNecatoramericanus
Abdominal pain • Hosts developed central abdominal pain about 3 weeks post-inoculation
Healthy Volunteers: • 1 of 3: developed vigorous local reaction • 3 of 3: Central, non-colicky abdominal pain started about 3.5 weeks and persisted for about 5 weeks