100 likes | 227 Vues
In this assignment, students are tasked with independently reading novels that explore the concept of heroism. They will produce a two-paragraph review of their chosen book, summarizing the plot and identifying the author's argument or theme supported by ethos, pathos, and logos with textual evidence. Additionally, students will create a Frayer model on the word "Hero" and analyze a real-life scenario involving the Carnegie Hero Award criteria. By engaging in discussions and pair-sharing, students will deepen their understanding of heroism and the arguments surrounding it. **Relevant
E N D
Crit ThinkingTopic: Hero College Prep 2-26-13
Independent Reading novels work • A 2 paragraph review of your book • It should include: • A BRIEF summary • The argument the author makes (theme) • How it is made (ethos, pathos, logos) • With textual evidence (quotes) • Did you like it???? • DUE MONDAY
Your Turn • Read “Love” • Create your frayer model on LOVE • On the back analyze the argument (theme) AND the types of arguments (claim, evidence, warrant structure) • State contrasting examples…if there are any
Hero • On your own, create a Frayer model on the word “Hero.” • Lets talk about it • What criteria did you come up with????
HEROISM • The Carnegie Hero Award
Hero Criteria • Look @ your hand out….the bullet points are the criteria by which the Carnegie committee judges heroism • Lets go over them for a sec
Scenario • Read the scenario….. • Lets talk about it • Should Curtis Dawson get the award? • USE THE CRITERIA TO JUDGE HIM
Reality… • Curtis Dawson received the award in 2005
Borderline… • Read Roger Terrapin’s story • On the back of the sheet • On your own, decide if he should get the award or not • Write your decision (CLAIM, EVIDENCE, WARRANT) • Claim: Criteria • Evidence: Examples • Warrant: a statement that explains why a piece of evidence makes a claim factual.
PAIR/SHARE • Pair up with a partner and convince them • Make note of your discussion in the “discussion notes” portion of your sheet • Don’t forget to detail the types of arguments made • INCLUDE: did your partner change your mind???? • SHARE WITH THE WHOLE CLASS