120 likes | 254 Vues
In this analysis of Tony Soprano's perspective on happiness from "The Sopranos," we delve into three distinct approaches: "whiners," "happy wanderers," and "Garry Cooper types." Tony expresses disdain for whiners, who he believes rely too much on therapy, while envying the carefree nature of happy wanderers. Aspiring to the composed, individualistic Garry Cooper type, he struggles with internal conflict as a mobster. By considering ancient philosophies from the Stoics to the Epicureans, we uncover the deeper truths about happiness, motivations, and the pursuit of a fulfilling life.
E N D
The SopranosChapter 3 Luis Velasquez
Tony onHappiness • Accordingto Tony there are threedifferentapproachestohappiness: • “whiners” • “Happywanderes” • “Gary Cooper Types”
Whiners • Tony worriesthattherapyismeantforwhinners • Tony Disdainswhinners
HappyWanderes • Tony enviesHappy Wanderers Happiness • Tony wouldhappilywonderthroughlife • He recognizesthisisnot a possibilityforhimforthefactthat he dealswiththemob
Garry Cooper Types • Tony aspires to be a Garry Cooper type • Socratesexplainsthathappinesis a matteroforganizing a harmonybetweenthepartsofourselves • Whenit comes tohappines, wehumanshaveoptionsdecidingwe are “victims” ofothers
TheAncientsonHappines • Wehumans, as well as Tony tendtothinkthathappinessdependsonacquiringcertainthings • AncientEthistsexplainthathappinessisnot a matterofmerelyhavingthings • Stoics • Epicureans • Greeks
Stoics • “Not even anabundanceofthesegoods….makedifferencetothehappiness, desirabilityorvaluesofotherslife”
Epicureans • Ifwedeeplythinkenoughabouthappinesswe come to realice thatneitherreputation, good, birth, wealth, andthepleasureofagebringhappiness • Tonys case: • Wealthybutnothappy
Greeks • Happinessis a matterofactivitiesandnotacquistions • Happinessis a matterofwhatwe do and how we do it
HappinessRequiresIntegratedMotivations • Wemostreflectonwhatwe are reallyafterfor • Tony Triestojustifyhismobactivitybecauseitallowshimtofinanciallysupporthisfamily • Mob activitybrigs Tony andhisfamily, much more problemsthanfinancial • Plato describes this as having a “civil war” withhimself
ObjectionToTheIntegratedMotivation • HappyLife=EthicalLife • Thereis no way a Badguy has internalharmony • Badguyslike Tony, seemsomethingthey are not • Pretendwhat he isnot
Gary Cooper • Quiet, Stoic, individualistic • Emotionallyrestrained • Tony