1 / 14

Frame Problem

Philosophy 141. Frame Problem. Ankit Awasthi R Lakshminarayan Bharadwaj Sudhanshu Chowdhary Vinay Chataraju Vipul Arora. Guide: Prof. Prashant Bagad. Frame problem origin and relevance. Origin : Artificial Intelligence McCarthy and Hayes (1969).

tammy
Télécharger la présentation

Frame Problem

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Philosophy 141 Frame Problem • Ankit Awasthi • R Lakshminarayan Bharadwaj • SudhanshuChowdhary • Vinay Chataraju • VipulArora Guide: Prof. PrashantBagad

  2. Frame problemorigin and relevance • Origin : Artificial Intelligence • McCarthy and Hayes (1969). • Matrix, Terminator, Minority report etc. (????) • Dennett(1978), Fodor(1987) …

  3. definition If we had a number of axioms to be performed in sequence we would have quite a number of conditions to write down that certain actions do not change the values of certain properties(fluents). In fact with ‘n’ actions and ‘m’ fluents , we might have to write down ‘mn’ such conditions. The chief motivation for frame problem is that most things don't change when an action is performed or an event occurs.

  4. Basic terms • Fluents: Properties whose values can change as a result of an action. • Effect Axioms: Axioms that state the effects of an action. • Frame Axioms: Axioms that state the non-effects of an action. • State: The collection of fluent values under consideration.

  5. An example Fluents: • House_color() Initial conditions ( t=0): • Furniture_position() House_color(Red) Furniture_position(#) Actions: • Paint(house,color): changes color of the house to ‘color’ • Rearrange(furniture,position): change the position of the furniture to ‘position’

  6. Example(CoNTD.) At t=0, take action Paint(House,Yellow) At t=1, What is the position of the furniture???

  7. Example(contd.) • The problem becomes even worse if we allow concurrent actions. • In this case frame axioms are in fact wrong . • An exception needed?? • A infinite regression………..

  8. Epistemological Aspects How “a cognitive creature … with many beliefs about the world” can update those beliefs when it performs an act so that they remain “roughly faithful to the world”? Given the action of picking up a tea cup how does a robot update your beliefs about the world (ambient temperature, current date, etc.)

  9. Computational aspect of frame problem • This is the question of how to compute the consequences of an action without the computation having to range over the action's non-effects. • ‘Sleeping dog’ strategy . • Appeal to relevance

  10. Bot battery example Problem statement: program a bot to search and obtain batteries if present. What if batteries are tied with a thread ???? What if you take every possibility into account, but in the process of evaluation a bomb explodes??

  11. Common Sense Frame problem • It is based on the notion that it might not possible to axiomatise even a significant portion of the real world . • Common sense reasoning deals with ill defined concepts. • The problem of ‘kinds’: precisely what constitutes a particular class. • The entire commonsense world seems populated with categories of things which we find immensely useful to think about in planning our daily getting around and yet which defy ‘precise definition’ .

  12. Approaches to solving Frame problem • A naïve approach could be to assign probabilities to events. • Resorting to Metaphysical concepts like “common sense law of intertia”.(Does it work??)

  13. Moot Questions!!

  14. Questions … !

More Related