80 likes | 203 Vues
Critique of Rob Bell’s Book Love Wins. Dr. Mike Stallard Baptist Bible Seminary. What is good about the book…. People are capable of viewing God as a God of judgment (p. 37) Earthly future for God ’ s kingdom (heaven and earth merge together – p. 42-43)
E N D
Critique of Rob Bell’s BookLove Wins Dr. Mike Stallard Baptist Bible Seminary
What is good about the book… • People are capable of viewing God as a God of judgment (p. 37) • Earthly future for God’s kingdom (heaven and earth merge together – p. 42-43) • Clear testimony of his salvation experience (p. 194)
General contents of the book… • The idea of hell in traditional Christianity is a violent , untrue doctrine • The afterlife has more continuity with the present life than usually believed • Universalism or an open-ended future is the only option that allows God’s love to win
What is wrong with the book…Style and Tone • Mocking, sarcastic tone • Raises false concerns and makes caricatures • Use of worst examples to make points
What is wrong with the book…Abuse of History • Misquotes Martin Luther and makes him a universalist (p. 106)
What is wrong with the book…Abuse of the Bible Examples: • John 3:16 (p. vii) • Phil. 2:10-11—every knee shall bow (p. 99) • Rev 21-22 – no blood and violence (p. 112) • John 14:6 – exclusive and inclusive (p. 154)
What is wrong with the book…Theological Problems Postmodern Strategies • Present is how the future will be (cp. Mt 22) • “Forever” is not a biblical category • Way of God is never violent (cp. Rev 19) • Lake of fire ignored for most part • No clear definition of the gospel
What is wrong with the book…The Issue Behind the Issue Postmodern Worldview • Questions to keep the conversation going not to find answers (remember Matt 22) • Rejection of anything harsh