1 / 13

Assessment of Inter-Rater Reliability in Patient Interviewing Skills: Vignette Analysis

This study evaluates inter-rater reliability of interviewing skills among healthcare professionals using a vignette method. The results indicate fair-to-good reliability on sub-items and good reliability on major items. Average ratings for various skills were analyzed, including rapport development, appropriate responses, data collection for differential diagnosis, and mental status examination. Key findings suggest areas for improvement, particularly in obtaining sufficient data for accurate diagnoses and conducting thorough patient interviews.

xenos
Télécharger la présentation

Assessment of Inter-Rater Reliability in Patient Interviewing Skills: Vignette Analysis

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Vignette 1 Results Overview • Inter-rater reliability on the sub-items was fair-good • Inter-rater reliability on the major items was good

  2. Vignette 1 Results Complexity of patient

  3. Vignette 1 Results Difficulty of interview

  4. Vignette 1 Results 1-1. Develops rapport with patient Average Rating 3.41 + 1.23 Consensus Score 3-4 Acceptable Range 2-5

  5. Vignette 1 Results 1-2. Responds appropriately to patient Average Rating 3.52 + 0.96 Consensus Score 3 Acceptable Range 3-4

  6. Vignette 1 Results 1-3. Follows cues presented by patient Average Rating 3.21 + 1.14 Consensus Score 3 Acceptable Range 2-4

  7. Vignette 1 Results 2-1. Obtains sufficient data for DSM Axes I-V differential diagnosis Average Rating 2.94 + 1.15 Consensus Score 2 Acceptable Range 2-4

  8. Vignette 1 Results 2-2. Obtains psychiatric, medical, substance use, family, and social histories Average Rating 3.07 + 1.21 Consensus Score 2-3 Acceptable Range 2-4

  9. Vignette 1 Results 2-3. Screens for suicidality, homicidality, high risk behavior, and trauma Average Rating 3.37 + 1.15 Consensus Score 3 Acceptable Range 2-5

  10. Vignette 1 Results 2-4. Uses open- and closed-ended questions Average Rating 3.61 + 1.35 Consensus Score 4-5 Acceptable Range 2-5

  11. Vignette 1 Results 2-5. Performs an adequate mental status examination Average Rating 2.35 + 1.13 Consensus Score 2 Acceptable Range 1-3

  12. Vignette 1 Results 1. Physician Patient Relationship Average Rating 3.15 + 1.04 Consensus Score 3 Acceptable Range 2-4

  13. Vignette 1 Results 2. Conduct of the Interview Average Rating 2.78 + 0.94 Consensus Score 2 Acceptable Range 2-4

More Related