1 / 36

Doing Business In India: Anti-Corruption Best Practices

Doing Business In India: Anti-Corruption Best Practices. Momentum Webinar May 29, 2014. Agenda. Introduction Overview of FCPA Corruption Challenges / Enforcement in India Compliance Best Practices Questions. India’s Business Potential …. Growing economy Barriers to entry eroding

cili
Télécharger la présentation

Doing Business In India: Anti-Corruption Best Practices

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Doing Business In India: Anti-Corruption Best Practices Momentum Webinar May 29, 2014

  2. Agenda • Introduction • Overview of FCPA • Corruption Challenges / Enforcement in India • Compliance Best Practices • Questions

  3. India’s Business Potential … • Growing economy • Barriers to entry eroding • Cost-competitiveness • Talent pool • Emerging middle class • Outpacing China in Foreign Direct Investment 3

  4. … and Business Challenges • Corruptioncited as second most problematic factor by World Economic Forum • Lack of infrastructure is ranked first • Others: • bureaucracy • tax regulations • restrictive labor regulations • administrative delays

  5. Overview of the FCPA

  6. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) • Prohibits briberyof non-U.S. government officials • Requires companies to maintain accurate records and robust internal controls • Regulators • Department of Justice (DOJ) • Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) 6

  7. Anti-Bribery Provisions • No covered person may make, offer, promise, or authorize, • Apayment or anything of value, • With corrupt intent, • To a government official, • To obtain or retain business or an unfair advantage. 7

  8. Payment • Can be an actual payment or gift • Can also be an offer or promise to pay • May be in response to request from official • It is enough to authorize a payment ** Includes direct and indirect payments** 8

  9. Thing of Value • Anything of value to the recipient • Money • Gift • Hospitality • Loan/favorable financing • Discounted/free maintenance • Donation • A job for official’s son / daughter 9

  10. Foreign Official • An officer, employee, or agent of any • Indian government, whether national, state, local, etc. • Department or agency of the Indian government • Company, entity, or other instrumentality owned/controlled by the Indian government • Public international organization (e.g., the UN, the WTO) • Indian political party 10

  11. Foreign Official (cont.) • Candidate for Indian political office • Anyone acting on behalf of a Foreign Official • Person holding ceremonial title (e.g., royal family member with no government position) • Rank or title is irrelevant 11

  12. Obtain Business / Advantage • Obtain contract from government agency • Achieve regulatory change that benefits business • Direct award of business opportunity to family member • Receive favorable ruling on applicable customs duties 12

  13. Permissible Payments • When permitted under written laws of country • Mere custom is not adequate OR • Reasonable and bona fideexpense directly related to: • Execution or performance of a contract with government party, or • Demonstration, promotion, or explanation of a product or service 13

  14. Facilitating Payments • Payments to expedite non-discretionary “routine governmental actions”such as: • Loading / unloading cargo • Award of a visa • Many companies prohibit facilitation payments entirely 14

  15. Third Party Risks Any party acting on your behalf, e.g., a • Subsidiary or other affiliate • Agent, sponsor, representative, distributor, consultant • Joint venture party Examples: • Your Customs broker in Mumbai • The lobbying firm you engage in Delhi • A marketing agent in Hyderabad 15

  16. Recordkeeping and Internal Controls • Keep detailed and accurate transactional records • Maintain system of internal controls to ensure management has oversightover and control of transactions • Obtain authorizations prior to transactions • Collect necessary approvals before reimbursement • Record transactions fully and accurately • Take steps so partners do the same 16

  17. Enforcement Related to India • Oracle (2012): Indian subsidiary involved in alleged bribery; $2 million fine to SEC • Diageo (2011): Subsidiaries in India (and elsewhere) alleged to have paid $2.7 million in bribes for sales and tax benefits; $16.4 million in penalties to SEC • Pride International (2010): Company apparently made $500,000 in improper payments to judges on India’s Customs, Excise, and Gold Appellate Tribunal; $32.6 million to DOJ and $19.3 million to SEC

  18. Enforcement (cont.) • Control Components Inc. (CCI) (2009): Allegedly made $4.9 million in illicit payments to officials in various countries, including Maharashtra State Electricity Board in India; $18.2 million in fines • Wabtec (2008): Subsidiary said to have made over $170,000 in payments to Indian Railway Board employees, inspectors, and customs personnel to obtain railway contracts; $300,000 to DOJ and $87,000 to SEC • Electronic Data Systems (EDS) and Srinivasan (2007): Former president of AT Kearney India caused ATKI to make over $720,000 in payments to employees of state-owned companies to retain contracts worth $7.5 million; Srinivasan paid $70,000 fine; EDS paid $490,902 in penalties

  19. FCPA Enforcement (cont.) • Wal-Mart: Company investigating wide-ranging bribery allegations • Company’s agents in India allegedly procured numerous licenses required for setting up stores • Partnered with Indian company to expand India operations; ended partnership amidst FCPA probe

  20. Corruption Challenges / Enforcement in India

  21. Corruption in India • Ranked 94 of 177 countries in TI’s 2013 Corruption Perceptions Index • Indian economists estimate government officials earn as much as 1.26% of GDPthrough corruption • Evidence of some companies halting business in India because of corruption

  22. Factors Contributing to Corruption • Government officials are poorly paid • General attitude toward bribery more relaxed • Bribery viewed as an accepted part of doing business • Cumbersome procedures/red tape • Officials have substantial discretion

  23. Highest Corruption Risks • Sales to government customers • Obtaining licenses, permits, and registrations • Clearing customs– paying duties and taxes; logistics (using freight-forwarders) • Navigating bureaucracy / complex laws

  24. Where Corruption is Pervasive • Vulnerable sectors • metals & mining • $194 billion lost in government sale of coalfields to companies without competitive bidding • aviation • Air India reportedly losing millions due to corruption and mismanagement of aircraft repairs • power & utilities • aerospace & defense • infrastructure & construction • telecoms

  25. Common Schemes and Themes • Small sums • Services already due: customs clearance, taxation, water and land records issuance • Use of agents and/or consultants • Slush funds or petty cash funds • Fictitious invoices • Indirect benefits – hiring third parties at official suggestion • Lavish gifts and entertainment • Donations to organizations owned/recommended by officials

  26. Potential Compliance Gaps • Improper gift-giving (cash, computers, large dollar travel) • “Check the box due” diligence – consider specific local factors to take risk-based approach • Improper use/oversight of third parties • Customer relationships built on trust – resistance to memorializing business agreements in formal contracts

  27. Indian Anti-Corruption Law • Limited in scope and enforcement • Prevention of Corruption Act (PCA) 1988 • India ratified United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) in 2011 • Lokpal Bill passed in December 2013; new agency established to investigate and prosecute

  28. Recent Events • In recent years, public has taken to streets to voice outrage after corruption scandals • January 2014 - $670 million helicopter deal with British-Italian company terminated due to corruption allegations • April 2014 – DOJ asked India to arrest member of Indian parliament who granted mining rights for $18 million in bribes • Modi’s election and pro-business platform

  29. Indian Government Investigations • 2010: Investigation of Commonwealth games in New Delhi • 2011: CBI arrested Chief and aides of organizing committee for awarding illegal contracts to Swiss manufacturer • Officials being tried for illegalities in issuing 2G telecom licenses – revenue losses reportedly $40 billion

  30. Compliance Best Practices

  31. Compliance Best Practices • Establish transparent tone at top • Prioritize / address risks • Tailor policies and procedures to risks • Keep good records

  32. Tone at the Top • Establish top-down culture of compliance • Regularly assert importance of compliance • Commit resources to compliance infrastructure • Dedicated compliance personnel • Regular training • Helpline / reporting mechanism

  33. Prioritize Risk • Expressly contemplated by DOJ and SEC Guidelines • Focus compliance resources on most significant risk areas such as: • Industry • Use / non-use of agents • Amount of interaction with government • Past compliance issues • Importance of cash to operation • Other factors

  34. Policies and Procedures • Establish processes for: • Vetting business partners • Providing hospitality and gifts • Monitoring and auditing compliance • Internal reporting mechanisms • Opportunity for anonymousreporting • Promptreview and investigation as needed • Protect personnel from retaliation when report is in good faith

  35. Questions?

  36. THANK YOU! Jennifer GormanAECOM Jennifer.Gorman@aecom.com Thad McBride Sheppard Mullin tmcbride@smrh.com Fatema Merchant Sheppard Mullin fmerchant@smrh.com

More Related