1 / 17

Communicating Research Results

Communicating Research Results. Aspects of tax research communication: Communications and the tax professional The file memo Evaluating the sources of law Client letters Oral presentations of research results. Communications and the Tax Professional. Audience Supervisor Client Other

mala
Télécharger la présentation

Communicating Research Results

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Communicating Research Results • Aspects of tax research communication: • Communications and the tax professional • The file memo • Evaluating the sources of law • Client letters • Oral presentations of research results

  2. Communications and the Tax Professional • Audience • Supervisor • Client • Other • Form • Telephone call • Informal discussion in person • E-mail • Letter • For tax professional • Tax knowledgeable/tax limited client • Memo

  3. The File Memo • The memo is for the researcher’s benefit • Purpose: • Organize facts, issues, and conclusions • Facilitate technical review by supervisor or colleague • Allow for subsequent examination of research issue

  4. The File Memo: Format and Content • Facts • Brief summary of relevant facts and issues • Issues • A list of tax issues being researched • Conclusions • Quickly determine whether each issue is “pro” or “con” for taxpayer

  5. The File Memo: Format and Content • Support • Detailed review and evaluation of controlling laws • Full citations • Strengths and weaknesses are developed • Actions to be taken • Recommendations for subsequent actions for client • Other strategies for tax positions

  6. The File Memo: Facts • Taxpayer will not always provide all relevant facts • Taxpayer may forget (potentially detrimental) facts • Taxpayer does not always know which documents are important • Must rely on taxpayer’s memory • Loss of records/witnesses • The researcher must use experience to obtain all the relevant facts from the taxpayer

  7. The File Memo: Links and Attachments • Only most important documents, such as • Case briefs • Highlighted copies of primary sources of law • Highlighted copies of explanatory material • Related in-house memos • Journal articles

  8. Evaluating Sources of Tax Law • Regulations seldom held to be invalid • Revenue Rulings and Revenue Procedures frequently modified or held invalid • Higher court decisions receive additional precedential weight • District and Circuit Court opinions directly affect only taxpayers in those jurisdictions

  9. Evaluating Sources of Tax Law • A well-written court case opinion contains a wealth of information on tax issues: • Identifies pertinent tax law • States competing interpretations of the law • Identifies critical facts and issues • Often includes lengthy concurring and dissenting opinions

  10. Evaluating the Sources of Law • Important Circuits • 2nd Circuit (includes New York) • Authoritative in traditional sense • 9th Circuit (includes California) • First to introduce innovative or unusual interpretations • Federal Circuit • Authoritative in traditional sense

  11. Evaluating the Sources of Law • Older cases • Geometrically declining importance, except for • Supreme Court cases • 2nd, 9th and Federal circuits • If it is the only precedent available • Court decisions can be unpredictable

  12. Evaluating the Sources of Law • Tax treatises and journals • Identify current, critical tax issues • Can include comprehensive summary of controlling law • IRS agents are only bound by • IRC • Administrative pronouncements • Supreme Court decisions

  13. Client Letters • Telephone calls to clients are prevalent • Should be followed up with a detailed letter • Letter should be brief • Sometimes easier to explain complicated issues in face-to-face meetings

  14. Client Letters: Format and Content • Salutation/social graces/general conclusion • Summary of results • Objective of research • Statement of facts/disclaimer

  15. Client Letters: Format and Content • Summary of critical sources • Implications of the results • Assumptions/limitations • Closing/reference to follow-up meeting/social graces • Attachments

  16. Effective Written Business Communication • Main point(s) in first paragraph • State well-defined purpose • Avoid filler language, clichés and jargon • Revise several times if needed • Use social amenities • Use edit and proofreading aids

  17. Client File • Client file includes • Client letter • File memo • Engagement letter • Billing and collection history • Relevant authoritative sources • Links to other important sources

More Related