360 likes | 2.65k Vues
PICO Question. Do women who deliver vaginally who do antenatal perineal massage, compared to women who have a routine episiotomy, have reduced perineal laceration and pain?. PICO Defined. Population: Women in labor who deliver vaginallyIntervention: Antenatal massage of perineumComparison: Performing a routine episiotomyOutcomes: Reduce perineal laceration and pain.
E N D
1. Antenatal Perineal Massage Krystal Jenkins, Cynthia Maxwell, and Kristi Watts
OU-Tulsa College of Nursing
2010
2. PICO Question Do women who deliver vaginally who do antenatal perineal massage, compared to women who have a routine episiotomy, have reduced perineal laceration and pain?
3. PICO Defined Population: Women in labor who deliver vaginally
Intervention: Antenatal massage of perineum
Comparison: Performing a routine episiotomy
Outcomes: Reduce perineal laceration and pain
4. Problem and Prevalence
Three million women give birth vaginally each year
Episiotomy rates have steadily declined over past 25 years
35% of mothers with a vaginal birth had an episiotomy.
Genital tract trauma can result from episiotomies,
spontaneous tears or both (Beckmann, 2)
Greater genital tract trauma results in greater postpartum
morbidity
(Albers, 3)
5. Definitions Perineum-Area between your vaginal opening and your
rectum
Routine Episiotomy-Incision to enlarge vaginal opening
Antenatal Perineal Massage- Using two fingers to stretch
your perineal tissues before birth
Genital Tract Trauma-Trauma to the genitals during
childbirth Perineum-This area stretches a lot during childbirth and sometimes tears.
Episiotomy- The perineum is the area that is cut by the physician. You will need stitches if an episiotomy is performed.
Genital tract trauma- Can impact the perineum, and vulva.Perineum-This area stretches a lot during childbirth and sometimes tears.
Episiotomy- The perineum is the area that is cut by the physician. You will need stitches if an episiotomy is performed.
Genital tract trauma- Can impact the perineum, and vulva.
6. Myths of Episiotomies Physicians concerned with perineal shatter
Physicians felt they were protecting the
perineum “by temporarily abolishing it”
Physicians believed episiotomies reduced the risk of:
Incontinence
Drooping of bladder and rectum into vagina
(Eason, 466)
Doctors felt multiple jagged lacerations would be harder to repair (Eason, 466)
Doctors felt multiple jagged lacerations would be harder to repair (Eason, 466)
7. Review of the Literature
8. Albers, (2007) Reviews research on the reduction of genital tract trauma and
related post-delivery pain
Evaluated two Randomized trials on the effects of perineal
massage
Findings:
Shipman found a 6% reduction in trauma
Labrecque found a 9% reduction in nulliparas
Education handout was distributed to women.
Labrecque found no significant difference in multiparous women.
Labrecque found no significant difference in multiparous women.
9. Beckmann, (2006) Included four randomized and quasi-randomized controlled
trials
Findings:
Antenatal perineal massage reduced overall incidence of
perineal trauma
Women were 16% less likely to have episiotomy
Restrictive use of episiotomy:
Less posterior perineal trauma
Less suturing
Fewer healing complications
Benefits:
Cost savings
2497 Women
Cost savings: Less suturing, drugs, analgesics.2497 Women
Cost savings: Less suturing, drugs, analgesics.
10. Eason, (2000) Randomized control trials of interventions affecting perineal trauma
Findings:
Avoiding episiotomy in 4.4 women prevents one case of trauma
46 of 47 women with anal sphincter tears had episiotomies
Fewer sutures and less time overall with restrictive episiotomies
11. Labrecque, (1999) Randomized single blind study
1,034 multiparous
493 nulliparas
At the 34th week of pregnancy women performed daily 10 minute massage
Findings: Women with intact perineums
In Nulliparas: 24% of massage group
15% of control group
In Multiparas: 35% of massage group
32% of control group
12. Eogan, (2006) An observational study of:
100 massage group
79 control group
Findings: Women with intact perineums
24% of women who massaged
15% of controls
In nulliparous women an increase of 6.2% in intact perineum
Significantly in women older than 30 years old
13. Pros of Restricted Use of Episiotomy “No benefits accompany the routine use of episiotomies”
Should be avoided except in rare situations
Restrictive use reduced healing time
(Eason, 465)
Use when infant is in extreme jeopardy.
Example:
Extensive vaginal tearing appears likely
Your baby is in an abnormal position
Your baby needs to be delivered quickly
Use when infant is in extreme jeopardy.
Example:
Extensive vaginal tearing appears likely
Your baby is in an abnormal position
Your baby needs to be delivered quickly
14. Advantages of Antenatal Massage Practiced more by Certified Nurse Midwives (Eason, 467)
Helps reduce perineal trauma and pain afterwards
Performed the last 4-6 weeks of pregnancy
More impact on nulliparas
Very non-invasive
Supported by many women
May be performed by the woman or her partner. May be performed by the woman or her partner.
15. Research Summary Practicing antenatal perineal massage at 34 weeks
protects perineal integrity (Beckmann, 7)
Restrictive use of episiotomies has better outcomes than
routine use (Eason, 464)
By reducing perineal trauma, postpartum morbidity will
improve
16. Recommendations Patients
Perform or have partner perform massage beginning at 34 weeks before delivery
Discuss restrictive use of episiotomy with physician prior to delivery
Nurses
Educate patients the positive outcomes associated with
antenatal massage
Educate patients the proper procedure and compliance
17. Rationale for Recommendations
Reasons to perform:
-Increases “stretchiness”
-Smaller chance of tearing or needing episiotomy
-Helps practice relaxing the muscles of the perineal area used during delivery
Lubricants: Vitamin E, Almond oil, Vegetable oil, Olive oil, KY Jelly
DO NOT USE: baby oil, mineral oil, or petroleum jelly
You want to feel a slight burning stretching sensation
This is a good time to practice slow, deep breathing techniques used in delivery.
Lubricants: Vitamin E, Almond oil, Vegetable oil, Olive oil, KY Jelly
DO NOT USE: baby oil, mineral oil, or petroleum jelly
You want to feel a slight burning stretching sensation
This is a good time to practice slow, deep breathing techniques used in delivery.
18. Techniques to perform perineal massage: Wash your hands well
Lubricate your thumbs and perineal tissues
Place thumbs 1 to 1.5 inches inside vagina
Press down and to the sides
Hold position for 1-2 minutes
With thumbs massage using “U” shaped movement
Perform for 10 minutes daily
19. Method for Evaluation Keep journals throughout pregnancy
Evaluate compliance of massage
Assessment at post-partum check ups
Evaluate patient satisfaction
20. Suggestions for Further Research More evidence needed regarding whether stretching massage during labor is helpful or harmful (Eason, 470)
Randomized trials of perineal massaging devices are needed (Beckmann, 8)
Factors affecting delivery such as pelvic floor exercises, general exercise and body mass index need to be examined (Albers, 10)
21. New Research Questions
Research on delivery techniques is needed:
- Does flexion of the fetal head affect perineal integrity?
-Does avoiding maternal pushing in the third stage of labor promote perineal integrity?
-Does preventing rapid delivery promote perineal integrity?
(Eason, 470)
22. References Albers, L., CNM, D., & Borders, N. C. (2007). Minimizing genital tract trauma and related pain following spontaneous vaginal birth. Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health , 52 (3), 246-253.
Eogan, M., Daly, L., O'Herlihy, C., (2006). The effect of regular antenatal perineal massage on postnatal pain and anal sphincter injury: A prospective observational study. Journal of Maternal - Fetal & Neonatal Medicine. Taylor & Francis Ltd. Retrieved March 24, 2010 from HighBeam Research: http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P3-1071473651.html
23. References Labrecque, M, E. E.-J. (1999). Randomized controlled trial of prevention of perineal trauma by perineal massage during pregnancy. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology , 180 (3), 593-600.
Beckmann, M.M., Garrett A.J. Antenatal perineal massage for reducing perineal trauma. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2006, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD005123. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD005123.pub2.
Eason, E., Labrecque, M., (2000). Preventing perineal trauma during childbirth: a systematic review. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. 95 (3), 464-471.