1 / 16

Ethics – Standing Alone

Ethics – Standing Alone. Shawn Winter Heatlh , Safety , Security, Environmental Consulate Studio Legale Lauro Naples , Italy Email : info@studiolegalelauro.it Office Telephone :0039.081.580.0199. India Assignment : 27 July to 02 August, 2015.

susanthompson
Télécharger la présentation

Ethics – Standing Alone

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Ethics – Standing Alone ShawnWinter Heatlh, Safety, Security, EnvironmentalConsulate Studio Legale Lauro Naples, Italy Email: info@studiolegalelauro.it Office Telephone:0039.081.580.0199

  2. India Assignment: 27 Julyto 02 August, 2015 ConversationbetweenPM-Project Manager and myself • Shawn: “The HSE GAP Report needstobe the first meeting tosee the progress ofyourfindings, not the HSE SIMOPS one, therebeennothingdonesinceSeptember 2014.” • PM: “Forgetyoueverreadit.” • Shawn: It’s notsafeytosendanyone out there, I amnotgoing.” • PM: “Wewillneversendanyone out tothatplatform.” • Shawn: “ Youhavealreadydid, Matt isthere.” • PM: No Reply. • What do you do??

  3. Floridia Bahamas Cuba Haiti and Dominican Republic Puerto Rico

  4. Massive Low Pressure Floridia Bahamas Floridia Floridia Bahamas Bahamas Cuba Cuba Cuba Puerto Rico Haiti and Dominican Republic Puerto Rico

  5. ElFara 33 Crew:28 US, 5 Polish

  6. TimeLine: 29 Sept – 1 Oct, 2015 Jacksonville to Puerto Rico • 26 -27 Sept: Massive rainstorm & floods on U.S. East Coast, a TropicalStormisbegining in Altantic. • 29 Sept: ElFaradeparts, TropicalStorm - 40 mphwinds. • 29 Sept: Forecasterspredicting a strengtheningstorm. • 30 Sept: Early AM upgrade toCategory 1 Hurricane. • 30 Sept: ElFara sent email – “…understood the weathercondition and have sound plan, crewwellprepared and briefed.” • 30 Sept – 1 Oct: StormstrengthsCategory 4 Hurricane, winds 145 mph, waves at 50 feet. • 1 Oct: Lostpower, taking on water, listing 15 degrees, sinks.

  7. Last message from El Faro: ‘There is a hurricane out here and we are heading straight into it’ Danielle Randolph Second Mate 2004 Maine MaritimeAcademy 34 yearsold

  8. TOTE Marine CEO’s statements: • Phil Greene, retired U.S. NavyAdmiral, President and CEO ofToteServices Inc., said the Captainhad a plantosailaheadof the hurricanewithroomtospare. • ElFaro's sistership — whichwasreturningto Jacksonville along a similarroute — and determined the weatherwasgoodenoughto go forward.

  9. TOTE Marine CEO’s statements: • 5 workers from Poland came along with 28 U.S. crew members to do some preparatory work in the engine room, work wasbeingdone on the engineroomduring the voyage — butthatwasn't a factor in the vessel's mysteriouspower loss. • Company officialssaidit's ultimately the Captain's responsibilityto come up with a voyageplan. • TOTE Management couldhavevetoed the trip.

  10. TOTE Marine CEO’s statements: • Built in 1975. • Modernized in 1992 and 2006.  • Ship lengthen 90 feet more. • February – 2015: American Bureau ofShippingcomplete hull and machinery inspections in with no red flags – no problem found. • March – 2015: Last annual Coast Guard inspection.

  11. National TransportationSafetyBoard • Since the shipislost…DataRecorder • Cluestowhathappenedmightbefound on shoreratherthan at sea. • Talkingto people whosailed on her last and before… • Blueprints. • Documentations, Audits, etc… • Commuincations, Emails. • Business Culture. • Company pressure to deliver the cargo on time.

  12. OtherIndividualsStatements: • “1975, that’s a long time ago for this type of ship.” • “It’s got all the problems of an aging ship.” • “The Ships age should not been a concern.” • “The Captain and Company Officalsmade a poordecisionto go tosea.” • “OftenpressureforCaptainsto stay on schedule.”

  13. EthicsImpact: • Teamwork • AssestProtection • DecisionMaking • Public Image • Business • InsuranceClaims • LawSuites

  14. Alfred Duff Cooper, BritishPoliticansaid in 1938: “…byvotingagainstthis, I haveruined, perhaps, mypolitical career. Butthisis a littlematter, I haveretainedsomething whichisto me ofgreatvalue – I can stillwalkabout the world withmy head erect!” • Thankyou

More Related