1 / 16

Operators' Opinions on the Proposed MOSS System vs. SSM: A Summary from 2010

This document summarizes operator responses regarding the proposed Marine and Offshore Safety System (MOSS) compared to the existing Safety Management System (SSM), as per the questionnaire conducted on July 30, 2010. Key findings reveal significant concerns about SSM, with 54.77% of respondents recommending its scrapping. Many operators find SSM inconsistent, complex, and costly, while opinions on MOSS indicate skepticism about its effectiveness and potential cost increases for surveys and audits. A majority express a desire for industry workshops to explore alternatives to SSM.

yvonne
Télécharger la présentation

Operators' Opinions on the Proposed MOSS System vs. SSM: A Summary from 2010

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. MTA Oral Submissions to MOSS Panel A summary of operators opinions on the proposed MOSS system 30 July 2010

  2. Question : Should SSM be Scrapped • Against 54 77.14% • For 11 15.71% • No Answer 5   7.14%

  3. What do you think is wrong with SSM? • Nothing 12 17% • Not Much 11 15.71% • Inconsistent 11 15.71 • Costs 7 10.00% • Too Complex 6 8.57% • Paperwork 10 14.29% • Costs 7 10.00% • Control 3 4.29% • No Answer 3 4.29%

  4. Do you think that SSM is confusing & unduly complex for industry? • Yes 30 42.86% • No 36 51.43% • No Answer 4 5.71%

  5. Does MNZ have effective oversight of safety under SSM? • Yes 30 42.86% • No 36 51.43% • No Answer 4 5.71%

  6. Does the Marine industry have a mediocre safety record under SSM? • Yes 14 20.00% • No 49 70.00% • No Answer 7 10.00%

  7. Do you think MOSS will be a better system than SSM? • Yes 13 18.57% • No 45 64.29% • Don’t Know 7 10.00% • No Answer 5 7.14%

  8. Do you want to leave your SSM company. • Yes 13 18.57% • No 48 68.57% • Don’t Know 0 0.00% • No Answer 9 12.86%

  9. Do you think survey costs will increase or decrease under MOSS? • Increase 52 74.29% • Decrease 6 8.57% • No Answer 12 17.14%

  10. Do you support MNZ conducting auditing under MOSS? • Yes 27 38.57% • No 31 44.29% • No Answer 12 17.14%

  11. Do you believe that the audit process will be consistent? • Yes 17 24.29% • No 36 51.43% • Don’t Know 6 8.57% • No Answer 11 15.71%

  12. Do you think audit costs will stay the same, increase or decrease if conducted by MNZ? • Increase 52 74.29% • Decrease 6 8.57% • Stay the same 2 2.86% % • No Answer 10 14.29

  13. Are you happy with the consultation undertaken so far by MNZ in developing MOSS? • Yes 16 22.86% • No 34 48.57% • No Answer 20 28.57%

  14. Would you like the opportunity for industry workshops to be conducted with MNZ to investigate alternative models for SSM? • Yes 50 71.43% • No 10 14.29% • No Answer 10 14.29%

  15. Are you happy with paying for exemptions and applications for private use? • Yes 7 10.00% • No 48 68.57% • No Answer 15 21.43%

  16. Summary of Questionnaire respondents • Fishing Boats 17 175 Meters Total Vessels 105 • Charter Boats 36 510 Meters Total Length 1892 m • Ferries 16 369 Meters Total Operators 70 • Vehicle Ferries 7 264 Meters • Workboats 11 376 Meters • Bare Boats 13 144 Meters • Aquaculture 2 24 Meters • Jet Boat 1 10 Meters • Sail Trainer 1 10 Meters • Water Taxi 1 10 Meters

More Related