210 likes | 500 Vues
Contraception. What is Contraception?. Any action undertaken to prevent conception or fertilization. Why Contraception?. For a committed couple to prevent ever having children For a committed couple to prevent having children for the present
E N D
What is Contraception? • Any action undertaken to prevent conception or fertilization
Why Contraception? • For a committed couple to prevent ever having children • For a committed couple to prevent having children for the present • For a non-committed partners to prevent having children
Types of Contraception • Permanent Sterilization • Vasectomy, tubal ligation • Barrier Method • Condom, diaphragm • Oral contraceptive • The pill, ECPs • Intrauterine devices (IUD) • Rhythm Method (natural family planning) • Withdrawal (coitus interruptus)
Catholic Sexual Ethics and Contraception: 4 documents; 4 Popes • Pope Pius XI: Casti Connubii, 1930 • Pope Pius XII: Address to Italian Midwives, 1951 • Vatican II : Gaudium et Spes, 1965 • Pope Paul VI: Humanae Vitae, 1968 • (Pope John Paul II wrote many works both before HV and since that expounded upon HV).
CastiConnubii • Pius XI • 1930 • In response to Episcopalian bishops who allowed contraception within marriages • Sex’s primary goal of sex is procreation • There are secondary goals (love and pleasure), • Those goals are to be “subordinated to the primary end and so long as the intrinsic nature of the act is preserved.”
Address to Italian Midwives • Pius XII • 1951 • Allows married couples to have sex during the infertile times of a woman’s cycle when there is good reason to do so • Medical • Economic • Social
Gaudium et Spes • Vatican II • Under Pope John XXIII • 1965 • On Joy and Hope • Acknowledges that conjugal love has a substantial value apart from procreation • However, the two are still not unrelated • Things still need to be discussed • Creates a commission on the study of marriage, family, and births so that the Pope can pass judgment.
Papal Commission on Population, Family, and Birth • Initlialized by John XXIII • 3 priests, 2 physicians, 1 economist • Paul VI enlarged it • First to 18 people • Then to 65 • Including single women and men, married couples, social scientists, bishops, Cardinals, etc. • 4 of the 65 said that current Church teaching should stand • Including Archbishop Karol Wojtyła • The rest said that there needed to be a change.
Humanae Vitae • Issued by Pope Paul VI • 1968 • Reaffirms that unitive and procreative cannot be divided. • No longer primary/secondary reasons • Leaves room for rhythm method/Natural Family Planning • Met with anger and dissent among laity, clergy, and even bishops and Cardinals • Particularly in the US
Ethical arguments for contraception • Sometimes, it’s immoral or socially irresponsible for a couple to have more children. • Couples need to express their love for one another; but they don’t always need to have children. • Natural family planning is just like non-artificial contraception. How can one be good and one be bad? • Disease control and population control are ethical issues, too.
Ethical arguments against contraception • Natural law clearly shows that sex is for procreation. Manipulating that goes against God and nature. • Artificial contraception is unnatural. • Creates a callous attitude towards sex • It makes it easier to enter into the sexual act without commitment or intentionality • Language of sex says “I love you entirely;” language of contraception says “I don’t love your fertility.” • Some contraceptives prevent implantation, not conception, which could be considered an abortion (the pill).