1 / 21

Sources of Funding Unit 1 AS

Access to Justice. Sources of Funding Unit 1 AS. Objectives. Explain what is meant by the unmet need for legal services Explain the history of state-funded legal services & the reforms of 1999 Explain the role of the Legal Services Commission

Télécharger la présentation

Sources of Funding Unit 1 AS

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Access to Justice Sources of Funding Unit 1 AS LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  2. Objectives • Explain what is meant by the unmet need for legal services • Explain the history of state-funded legal services & the reforms of 1999 • Explain the role of the Legal Services Commission • Explain the workings of the Community Legal Service & the Criminal Defence Service • Identify other providers of advice / alternative sources of help • Critically evaluate the Access to Justice Act 1999 • Explain & evaluate conditional fee agreements • Identify & discuss further proposals/ areas for reform LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  3. Discussion Questions Q. What is legal aid ? • State- funded legal help Q. What is meant by the unmet need for legal services? • A person has a problem which could possibly be solved by going to law, but that person is not able to get the help he / she needs from the system. Q. For what reasons do you think someone would fail to get the legal help they need? LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  4. Equity Q. For what reasons do you think someone would fail to get the legal help they need? • Person fails to see that their problem has legal implications • Chooses not to pursue the case because of implications like cost, sees solicitors as unapproachable • Person does not know of the existence of a legal service or cannot find one who could help LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  5. History of Legal Aid • 1949 – 1st state-funded legal aid scheme • 1980’s – system had developed into 6 different schemes • Legal Aid Board – administered the schemes • Cost of the system escalating • 1999 – Access to Justice Act 1999 – major changes to the system LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  6. Group Exercise • In small groups carry out the following exercise, you will be required to feedback your proposals to the class You are the Government you are required to draw up a new legal aid scheme, you need to consider the types of cases you will fund, eligibility rules etc. LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  7. Legal Aid before 1999 6 schemes • Legal advice & assistance scheme( the ‘green form’ scheme) • Assistance by way of representation (ABWOR) • Civil legal aid • Criminal legal aid • Duty solicitor- police stations • Duty solicitor – magistrates’ courts LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  8. Legal Aid before 1999 Problems with the 6 schemes • Eligibility levels dropped • Under funding of system • Fraud ad misuse f the system • Poor standards of work • Patchy coverage LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  9. Access to Justice Act 1999 Key changes • Legal Aid Board replaced with Legal Services Commission • Community Legal Services Partnerships developed • Introduction of a quality mark • 6 schemes replaced with 2 new schemes: • Community Legal Service • Criminal Defence Service LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  10. Access to Justice Act 1999 The Community Legal Service • Civil Cases • Funding no longer demand led – Funding Code • Means & Merits tests • Contract required from LSC to provide advice & representation • Certain cases removed from legal aid – personal injury, defamation & malicious falsehood, business disputes & cases relating to companies, partnerships, trusts, boundary disputes • Community legal advice - 2004 LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  11. Access to Justice Act 1999 The Criminal Defence Service • Criminal Cases • Funding is still demand led • Public defenders - 2001 • Duty solicitors • Contract required from LSC to provide state-funded criminal defence work • Means test abolished by AJA 199 • Criminal Defence Service Act 2006 – reintroduced means test • Criminal Defence Service Direct LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  12. Other Legal Service Providers Other than solicitors and barristers what other agencies / persons offer legal advice? • Law centres • Community Legal Advice Centres • Citizens’ Advice Bureaux • LA’s • Trade Unions • Motoring organisations • Pro Bono clinics • Insurance LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  13. Advantages of AJA Reforms • Better control over costs – civil cases now fixed budget • Higher standards of work – only those firms with a contract can provide legal services • Quality mark – reinforces high standards • Resources better allocated – the Funding Code channels money into those areas where it is needed LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  14. Disadvantages of AJA Reforms • Limited access to justice • Cost cutting - concerns that civil cases will suffer because priority given to criminal cases • No legal aid for defamation cases – McLibel Two (Steel v UK (2005) ) • Other cases removed from legal aid – business disputes and PI cases • Problems with conditional fee agreements • Public defenders – are they truly independent? ( See research by Cyrus Tata & Others (2004) on success of public defenders in Scotland • Poorer standards of work • Huge costs of criminal cases LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  15. Conditional Fee Agreements Courts & Legal Services Act 1990 & Access to Justice Act 1999 How do they work? • Solicitor can agree to take no fee, or a reduced fee if they lose, and raise their fee by a agreed percentage if they win ( maximum of double usual fee) • Extra fee is called the ‘uplift’ or ‘success fee’ • Loser pays winner’s costs and the uplift and if the court orders the insurance premium also if insurance has been taken out • Access to Justice Act 1999 – conditional fee available for all cases except medical negligence LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  16. Advantages of Conditional Fee Agreements Widen access to justice • Cost to the state – they cost the state nothing • They encourage solicitors to perform better • Widen coverage – defamation & tribunal cases allowed to use a conditional fee agreement • Requirement for insurance • Very popular with the public LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  17. Reforms and Proposals • LSC piloting community legal and advice centres • One-stop shops in doctors’ surgeries, community centres • Expansion of Community Legal Advice – telephone & website service providing advice on civil matters • A National legal service – similar to the NHS • Encourage use of ADR • Introduction of no-fault compensation & class actions LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  18. Reforms and Proposals • Lord Carter's review, Legal aid: a market-based approach to reform (2006) • Government paper, Legal Aid: a sustainable future(2006) Recommendations include: • Procurement contracts & Competitive tendering • Introduction of fixed fees for cases • Granting fewer & larger contracts • Aim of reforms to control costs & quality LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  19. Research Exercise Research Lord Carter's proposals and discuss whether they will have a positive or negative effect on the future of legal services. LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  20. Useful Websites www.legalservices.gov.uk www.clsdirect.org.uk www.dca.gov.uk www.communitylegaladvice.org.uk www.publications.parliament.uk – Carter’s review 2007 LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

  21. Test Yourself • What is the name of the Act that introduced the 2 new legal aid schemes? • What are the names of those 2 schemes? • How is each scheme funded / who is eligible? • When & by what Act were conditional fee agreements introduced? • What is the ‘uplift’? • What other providers are there of legal advice? • What are Lord Carter’s main proposals for reform? LA1: Understanding Legal Structures and Processes

More Related