Enhancing Circuit Equivalence Checking through Appearance-Based Methods

1. Appearance-based Equivalence Checking Speaker: Ching-Yi Huang Advisor: Chun-Yao Wang Date: 2011/05/06

2. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

3. Introduction • What is equivalence checking? • Given: • Two combinational circuits. Golden circuit and revised circuit. • Objective • Check whether the functionality of two given combinational circuits are equivalent.

4. Introduction • Functionality equivalence I1 O1 C1 Im On o1 C2 on

5. Introduction • Traditional methods • Truth table • ATPG-based • BDD-based • SAT-based

6. Our Approach • Appearance-based approach • Don’t build BDDs • If two circuits are equivalent, there should be a rule to transform their appearance into the same one.

7. Our Approach • Given: • Two combinational circuits. Golden circuit and revised circuit. • Objective • Observe their appearances • Transform the appearance (by rewiring techniques) of one circuit into a new circuit which is the same as the other according to the rules.

8. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

9. Overview An action per round For eliminating the rectification networks

10. Structure • AIG = AND-Inverter Graph • DAG = Direct Acyclic Graph • Two Inputs AND gate node • Inverter on the edge B C F A

11. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

12. Observation • Examples B B C A F F A C

13. Observation • Look at the nodes of the same level B B C A F F A C

14. Observation • Create necessary node/ Delete surplus node B B C A F F A C B A C

15. Observation • Create transform ID (TID) 1 1 1 B B A A F F A 2 A C 2 C

16. Observation • Next level 1 1 F F A 2 2

17. Observation • Observe next level 1 1 F F A 2 2

18. Observation • Observe next level • Rewiring 1 1 F F A 2 2

19. Observation • Observe next level • Gate Replacement (change phases) 1 1 v v F F 2 2

20. Rule & Decision • So… let us conclude the rules • 1. Create node • Add wire when patch it • 2. Delete node • Remove wire • 3. Remove wire • 4. Change fanin • Remove wire • Add wire (could be more smart) • 5.Gate replacement

21. Rule & Decision • 1. Create node B B A A F F A 1.Create node C 2. Add wire A C

22. Rule & Decision • 2. Delete node B B C C F F A A Remove wire C

23. Rule & Decision • 4. Change Fanin 1 1 F F 2 3

24. Rule & Decision • 4. Change Fanin 1 1 F F 2 3 3

25. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

26. EIR • Error Modeling • Removal • Addition • Replacement • Propagate fault • Find TAs • Choose destination • Rectification

27. Model the errors (AIG format) • Remove wire

28. Model the errors (AIG format) • Add wire a a a a b b

29. Model the errors (AIG format) • Replacement

30. Model the errors (AIG format) • Replacement

31. EIR • Destination Ⅱ Ⅰ Ⅲ error effect . . . . . .

32. EIR Algorithm • Region I/II • DON/DOFF = AND(TA) • If the error effect propagated to gd is 1/0, the corrected function for the error effect is • If the error effect propagated to gd is 0/1, the corrected function for the error effect is • If both 1/0 and 0/1 error effects are propagated to gd, the corrected function is either or

33. EIR Algorithm • Region III gdg(TA)= the cofactor of gd with respect to TA in good circuit • DON: • DOFF: • Corrected function: or

34. Rectification Issue • Choose where? • Considering that we want to eliminate the rectification networks in the future…

35. Choose the PO as destination • Choose the PO as destination!? • PO is the common dominator! • How about the multi-PO circuit? B C D A E F G

36. Partition • Multiple POs C1 i1 P1 i2 P2 i3 P3 i4

37. Partition • Partition by POs • How about the overlapping part? • Duplicate the common part in both circuits! C1 i1 P1 i2 P2 i3 P3 i4

38. Partition • Partition and duplicate C1 i1 i1 P1 P1 i2 i2 P2 P2 i3 i3 P3 P3 i4 i4 C2

39. Partition • Partition and duplicate i1 C1-1 P1 i2 i2 C1-2 P2 i3 i3 P3 C1-3 i4 i1 C2-1 P1 i2 i2 C2-2 P2 i3 i3 P3 C2-3 i4

40. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

41. Optimization • Node-merging w1 w1 w2 w2 nt nt w3 w3 w4 ns ns w4

42. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

43. Flow chart Start N If now_leveli < max_level optimization End Y Collect the node of level i Mark the nodes Y N Are all nodes dealt with? Observe one node in the same level Decide the action now_level ++ EIR

44. Flow chart (EIR) Start Receive Action Model error Fault Activation Fault Propagation Rectification & rewiring Re-levelization Circuit Simplification End

45. Flow Chart Receive Action Start N Model error If now_leveli < max_level optimization End Y Collect the node of level i Fault Activation Mark the nodes Fault Propagation Y N Are all nodes dealt with? Observe one node in the same level Rectification & rewiring Decide the action now_level ++ Re-levelization Circuit Simplification

46. Outline • Introduction • Approach • Methodology • Overview • Observation and Transformation Rules • Error Injection-based Rewiring (EIR) • Circuit Optimization • Flow Chart • Implementation • Correctness Verification • Circuit Simplification • Experiment Results • Future work

47. Correctness Verification • Two-stage: • Stage 1: • Everywhere and every case • Recover the circuit every time • Stage 2: • Focus on checking the correctness in the condition that there are some new nodes in the circuit • No recovery • Need threshold • Verify by SIS tool (output and original)

48. Correctness Verification • Removal • Stage 1 • For every node(source) to its every fanout(target) • Remove the wire(source->target) • Recover the circuit • Stage 2 • For every node to its every fanout (but not include the new fanouts patched in this round) • Remove the wire(source->target)

49. Stage 1 B B B B B B A A A A A A F F F F F F C C C C C C

50. Stage 2 Rectification network Rectification network B B B B A A A A F F F F C C C C Rectification network