1 / 16

Cartoon Wars: An Application of Hall’s Theory to Social Constructs of the Enemy

Cartoon Wars: An Application of Hall’s Theory to Social Constructs of the Enemy. By Meg Frechette. introduction. “Good Guy” v. “Bad Guy” How is this idea constructed? The power of propaganda during war. Constructed enemy versus Reality. research question.

demont
Télécharger la présentation

Cartoon Wars: An Application of Hall’s Theory to Social Constructs of the Enemy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Cartoon Wars:An Application of Hall’s Theory to Social Constructs of the Enemy By Meg Frechette

  2. introduction • “Good Guy” v. “Bad Guy” • How is this idea constructed? • The power of propaganda during war. • Constructed enemy versus Reality

  3. research question How do does the United States construct their enemy in political cartoons during times of war and what are the implications of this construct?

  4. literature review: wars • WWI (1914-1918) U.S, France, U.K, Russia, Italy. versus Germany, Austia-Hungry, Ottoman Empire, Bulgaria • WWII (1939-1945) U.S, British Empire, U.S.S.R, (China) versus Germany, Japan, Italy • Vietnam (1959-1975) U.S., Republic of Vietnam (S. Vietnam) versus Democratic Republic of Vietnam (N. Vietnam) • Iraq (2003-Present) U.S., Multi-National Force, UN Assistance Mission, NATO Training Mission, Iraq (post-Saddam Hussein), Turkey versus Iraq (under Saddam Hussein), al-Qaeda in Iraq, Islamis Army of Iraq, Baath Party Loyalists, Insurgent Groups

  5. literature review:cartoons Harry Katz(2004) • William Hogarth – 1700s • Benjamin Franklin “Join or Die” (1757) • Great Depression • Current Day Cartoonists

  6. literature review:propaganda and the enemy Sam Keen (1986) • Propaganda meant to Paralyze Thought • Cultural Differences • Reality of Enemy

  7. theory: Stuart Hall (1996) • How Nation constructs identity • Narrative of the nation • Origins, continuity, tradition, and timelessness • Invention of tradition • Foundational myth • Pure, original people, or ‘folk’ • Shaped by those in power

  8. methodology: • Historical Content Analysis • Gathered From Online Search • “Vietnam political cartoons” or “WWI editorial cartoons” • Cartoons Collected: • Iraq – 119 • Vietnam – 54 • WWII – 48 • WWI – 19 • Coding Sheet • Strengths and Weaknesses

  9. findings: • Weapons Present • Tone • Mocked or Feared • Humanized v. Dehumanized • Group v. Individual

  10. discussion:weapons and tone

  11. discussion:humanized v. dehumanized

  12. discussion:dehumanized

  13. discussion:group v. individual V.

  14. conclusion and further research • Enemy is merely construct to create unity • “Them” v. “Us” • Need to reinforce cultural awareness

  15. Questions?

  16. discussion:humanized

More Related