130 likes | 252 Vues
This overview of Participative Decision Making (PDM) explores its advantages and disadvantages. PDM can lead to positive outcomes like greater information sharing, diverse approaches, and increased acceptance of decisions. However, challenges such as premature conclusions, individual dominance, and conflicting ideas may arise. The Vroom-Yetton model highlights when to effectively implement PDM within groups. Key components for success include trained participants, communication, trust, and active participation. Learning to manage discussions and facilitate consensus is crucial for effective teamwork and decision-making.
E N D
POSITIVE RESULTS | | | | | | | | | NEGATIVE RESULTS YOUR GROUPS
TEAMS (AI) (GII) HIERARCHICAL PDM TEAM
HIERARCHICALTEAM (AI) GOAL GOAL GOAL GOAL TASK TASK TASK TASK TASK TASK “TEAMWORK IS A LOT OF PEOPLE DOING WHAT I SAY.” (MKT.EXEC, CITRIX CORPORATION)
PARTICIPATIVE DECISION MAKING(PDM) POSSIBLE ADVANTAGES: • GREATER INFORMATION • MORE APPROACHES • INCREASED ACCEPTANCE • BETTER COMPREHENSION OF DECISION
PDM POSSIBLE DISADVANTAGES: • PREMATURE DECISIONS • INDIVIDUAL DOMINATION • CONFLICTING SOLUTIONS • PRIOR COMMITMENT • AMBIGUOUS RESPONSIBILITY
PDM +OR -? • DISAGREEMENT • CONFLICTS • TAKING RISKS • TIME REQUIREMENTS
PDM WHEN TO USE? VROOM-YETTON MODEL
PDMWHEN TO USE(NORMAN MEIER) GROUP CONFERENCE LEADERSHIP HIGH ACCEPTANCE FLIP COIN EXPERT/ LEADER LOW LOW HIGH QUALITY
PDMPRECONDITION: ***TRAINED GROUP*** • COMMUNICATION • TRUST • ACTIVE • TAKE RESPONSIBILITY • PROBLEM SOLVING
COMPONENTS OF PDM • LEADER • SELECT PARTICIPANTS (QUALIFIED) • STATE CONSTRAINTS • LEADER NOT STATE OPINION
PROTECT QUALITY PROTECT ACCEPTANCE MANAGE VOCAL PEOPLE DRAW OUT QUIET MANAGE MEETING COMPONENTS OF PDM
Listen to understand Willingness to change position All members generally participating Trying out new ideas on each other Finding stimulation in disagreement Interacting and reaching consensus PDM: EFFECTIVE ACTIVITIES
Selling preferred opinions Listening to refute/not listening at all Defending one’s position to the end A few members dominating Reacting unfavorably to disagreement Converting others by 1-to-1 attempts PDM: INEFFECTIVE ACTIVITIES